Psychiatric wills of mental health professionals: a survey of opinions regarding advance directives in psychiatry

Abstract

Psychiatric wills are advance directives for an eventual involuntary treatment in psychiatry. We attempted to determine psychiatric professionals' knowledge and opinion about this legal option and obtain their formulations of advance directives for themselves. A total of 101 psychiatric nurses and psychiatrists at the Department of Psychiatry of the University of Vienna responded to a questionnaire about psychiatric wills and anonymously drafted advance directives for themselves concerning psychiatric treatment in case of an acute psychosis. Fifty-four percent knew about this legal option, 55% considered it an appropriate legal possibility, and 29% considered it inappropriate. The study also found that 75% of respondents reject certain methods of therapy, e.g. 30% want to exclude the use of neuroleptic medications, and 46% reject ECT. We conclude that although there is little experience so far with advance directives for psychiatric patients, there is an interest and predominance of positive attitudes towards this legal option among mental health professionals. Concerning their preferences, professionals felt inclined to make very specific statements as to which available treatment strategies they would reject and which they would request for their treatment. This bodes well for the widespread use of advance directives in mental health settings.

Understanding the Personal and Clinical Utility of Psychiatric Advance Directives: A Qualitative Perspective

“…A number of studies report varying levels of clinician support for PADs. These estimates range from a low of 20% to over 80% of clinicians indicating their support for PADs (Amering et al, 1999;Atkinson, Garner, & Gilmore, 2004;Backlar et al, 2001;Elbogen et al, 2006;Srebnik 2004). Given the novelty of PADs, such varying rates of PADs endorsement, particularly the lower rates, are not surprising.…”

A preliminary description of the use of ‘Relapse Management Cards’ in anorexia nervosa

“…The use of advance directives in medicine in general and psychiatry in particular is currently a topic for debate both in the United Kingdom and elsewhere (Amering, Denk, Griengl, Sibitz, & Stastny, 1999). An advance directive is drafted to allow an individual, who is competent, to dictate their care in the event that they become incompetent at a future date.…”

Medical futility and psychiatry: Palliative care and hospice care as a last resort in the treatment of refractory anorexia nervosa

“…8 Once these acute issues are managed, death may be a less likely outcome. The lack of consideration of futility in psychiatry may result from a commonly held view that, except for suicide or accidental overdose, people cannot die from psychiatric disorder.…”

“…Precipitating factors may entail presenting as danger to self or others or inability to care for oneself. 8 Alternatively, if the clinical condition is viewed as volitional, treatment refusal may be thought to signify a pre-contemplative state, in which case clinicians may use motivational interviewing techniques to attempt to move patients toward increasing readiness to engage in treatment voluntarily. 9 In practice, the spectrum of patients' displays of denial, minimization, treatment refusal and ambivalence about treatment is often more complex.…”