Public Versus Private Sector Wage Gap in Egypt: Evidence From Quantile Regression on Panel Data

Abstract

This paper considers the public and private sector wage earners in Egypt and examines their wage distribution during 1998-2012 using Egyptian Labor Market Panel Survey. We estimate the publicprivate sector wage gap with Mincer wage equations both at the mean and at different quantiles of the wage distribution. In this process we take into account observable and unobservable characteristics of the individuals using the panel feature of the data with a fixed effects model. We address sector of employment selection issue for both males and females. We find that there is very little evidence of sample selection in our data. Therefore, we present both the selection corrected results and the results with no selection correction. We find a persistent public sector wage penalty for males and public sector wage premium for females in the face of extensive sensitivity checks. They are larger when unobserved heterogeneity is taken into account for males but insignificant for females. They are similar across the quantiles for males but, smaller at the top than at the bottom of the conditional wage distribution for females. We further examine the public sector wage gap over time and in different sub-groups according to age and education. The public sector wage penalty for males has decreased recently over time and is larger for the better educated and younger. We also find substantial regional differences in public sector wage gap for males. JEL: C21, C23, J16, J31, J45

Are public sector workers in developing countries overpaid? Evidence from a new global dataset

“…By contrast Coppola and Calvo-Gonzalez (2011) show that in Peru there is a public sector wage premium in monetary compensation which disappears and instead turns into a public sector wage penalty when bonuses and in-kind payments are included in the analysis. In their estimates of public sector earnings gaps in the Arab Republic of Egypt, Tansel, Keskin and Ozdemir (2018) address issues of unobservable differences between public sector workers using panel data and individual fixed effects. They find public sector earnings penalties for men but premiums for women.…”

Female Labor Force Participation in Five Selected MENA Countries: An Age-Period-Cohort Analysis (Algeria, Egypt, Jordan, Palestine and Tunisia)

“…This was attributed to declining public employment opportunities of the educated women when the guaranteed employment scheme has ceased in the 1990's. This caused educated women to drop out of the labor force rather than take up informal employment which is not socially acceptable (Assaad and E-Hamidi, 2009;Assaad, 2014;Tansel et al, 2020). Assaad et al (2020) make the similar conclusions as the reasons for the stagnant FLFPs in Algeria, Egypt, Jordan and Tunisia in the face of substantial increase in educational attainments.…”

Female Labor Force Participation in Five Selected Mena Countries: An Age- Period-Cohort Analysis (Algeria, Egypt, Jordan, Palestine and Tunisia)

“…This was attributed to declining public employment opportunities of the educated women when the guaranteed employment scheme has ceased in the 1990's. This caused educated women to drop out of the labor force rather than take up informal employment which is not socially acceptable (Assaad and E-Hamidi, 2009;Assaad, 2014;Tansel et al, 2020). Assaad et al (2020) make the similar conclusions as the reasons for the stagnant FLFPs in Algeria, Egypt, Jordan and Tunisia in the face of substantial increase in educational attainments.…”