Due to the rapid development of technology, the higher demands of internet network users who want a form of network that can provide maximum results are increasing. In this case, Routing is one of the critical components of the network infrastructure on the Internet today, but routing performance on the router will increasingly burden the performance of the router. Consequently, it needs the addition of network scenario or management for backbone that has been built. In this case, the performance is compared to the addition of VLAN management scenarios on OSPF and combination of OSPF with VPLS Management over MPLS. The VLAN management on OSPF has the best performance, which gets throughput value up to 59.6%, packet loss up to 0.32%, jitter and delays 4.44 ms respectively.