Quantification of Neighborhood-Level Social Determinants of Health in the Continental United States

Abstract

IMPORTANCE An association between social and neighborhood characteristics and health outcomes has been reported but remains poorly understood owing to complex multidimensional factors that vary across geographic space. OBJECTIVES To quantify social determinants of health (SDOH) as multiple dimensions across the continental United States (the 48 contiguous states and the District of Columbia) at a small-area resolution and to examine the association of SDOH with premature mortality within Chicago, Illinois. DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS In this cross-sectional study, census tracts from the US Census Bureau from 2014 were used to develop multidimensional SDOH indices and a regional typology of the continental United States at a small-area level (n = 71 901 census tracts with approximately 312 million persons) using dimension reduction and clustering machine learning techniques (unsupervised algorithms used to reduce dimensions of multivariate data). The SDOH indices were used to estimate age-adjusted mortality rates in Chicago (n = 789 census tracts with approximately 7.5 million persons) with a spatial regression for the same period, while controlling for violent crime. MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURES Fifteen variables, measured as a 5-year mean, were selected to characterize SDOH as small-area variations for demographic characteristics of vulnerable groups, economic status, social and neighborhood characteristics, and housing and transportation availability at the census-tract level. This SDOH data matrix was reduced to 4 indices reflecting advantage, isolation, opportunity, and mixed immigrant cohesion and accessibility, which were then clustered into 7 distinct multidimensional neighborhood typologies. The association between SDOH indices and premature mortality (defined as death before age 75 years) in Chicago was measured by years of potential life lost and aggregated to a 5-year mean. Data analyses were conducted between July 1, 2018, and August 30, 2019. RESULTS Among the 71 901 census tracts examined across the continental United States, a median (interquartile range) of 27.2% (47.1%) of residents had minority status, 12.1% (7.5%) had disabilities, 22.9% (7.6%) were 18 years and younger, and 13.6% (8.1%) were 65 years and older. Among the 789 census tracts examined in Chicago, a median (interquartile range) of 80.4% (56.3%) of residents had minority status, 10.2% (8.2%) had disabilities, 23.2% (10.9%) were 18 years and younger, and 9.5% (7.1%) were 65 years and older. Four SDOH indices accounted for 71% of the variance across all census tracts in the continental United States in 2014. The SDOH neighborhood typology of extreme poverty, which is of greatest concern to health care practitioners and policy advocates, comprised only 9.6% of all census tracts across the continental United States but characterized small areas of known public health crises. An association was observed between all SDOH indices and age-adjusted premature mortality rates in Chicago (R 2 = 0.63; P < .001), even after accounting for vio...

Medical and Mental Health Comorbidities Among Minority Racial/Ethnic Groups in the United States

“…Covariate variables associated with comorbid conditions, included education level, household income, and age. From the historical record and previous studies, we know that discrimination plays a role in educational attainment and income levels, which alludes to the greater impact of discrimination on not just health, but other factors that influence health including social determinants of health (Knapp & Hall, 2018;Kolak et al, 2020). Importantly though, even when controlling for these other known social determinants of health, participants' race remained a significant predictor.…”

“…For minority racial/ethnic populations, stress arising from discrimination may play a role in terms of the physiological response to chronic stress, which has been linked to poor health outcomes among minority populations (Carter et al, 2017;Gee et al, 2007;Williams 2018). Additionally, discrimination can have community level impact by influencing availability of housing options, food insecurity, and access to health services, all of which are shown to be associated with poor health outcomes (Knapp & Hall, 2018;Kolak et al, 2020).…”

The intersection of genomics and big data with public health: Opportunities for precision public health

“…Another example is the use of neighborhood deprivation metrics that can assess health outcomes and disparities within regions (for example, affluent towns may have pockets of health deprivation) [ 23 ]. Another example is a recent study [ 24 ] of census tracts across the US that classified social determinants of health measures using indices of advantage, isolation, opportunity, and migrant cohesion and accessibility. The analysis was conducted by 7 neighborhood typologies, which included an extreme poverty group.…”

Describing the density of high-level trauma centers in the 15 largest US cities

“…Social determinants of health are associated with violence. 18 Violent crime data were collected from Federal Bureau of Investigation Uniform Crime Reports Offenses Known to Law Enforcement Search Engine. 19 Violent crime data included rates per 100 000 of homicide, rape, robbery, aggravated assault and total violent crime.…”