“…Though the data clearly indicate that product cyclization speeds up ligation reactions when substoichiometric template is used, the observed efficiency still is inferior to the efficiencies reported for templated reactions without ligation, such as acyl transfer, [25,26,[58][59][60]62] Wittig transfer, [61] transition metal catalysis, [64,65] or nitrogen release reactions. [24,44,45,47,49,50,52,56,57] We performed melting experiments to assess the template affinities of the molecules involved in the templated ligation-cyclization reaction (Figure 4). The melting temperature (T M ) of the PNA-DNA duplex comprised of cyclic PNA 9 and template T was 11 8C lower (T M = 46 8C) than that of the corresponding linear (cyclization-deficient) duplex 22·T (T M = 57 8C).…”