Rationality and Logic Castigation from the Western Scholarly Perspective Towards Allegations of Anti-Hadith Groups

Wazir, Rosni; Usman, Abur Hamdi; Syopiyan, Mohamad Jarpani; Nasir, Mohd Norzi

doi:10.1166/asl.2017.10165

Cited by 2 publications

(1 citation statement)

References 0 publications

Supporting

Mentioning

Contrasting

Order By: Relevance

“…However, without contradictory evidence or a compelling argument, Muslim hadith scholars and jurists generally regard a statement ascribed to the Prophet as something he uttered. A scholar was expected to conduct a critical analysis of a hadith only if he or she had compelling reasons to dispute its validity (Brown, 2009;Wazir, Usman, Syopiyan, & Nasir, 2017).…”

Section: Results and Discussion The Fabricated Hadith: History And Di...mentioning

confidence: 99%

How to Deal with the Fabricated Hadith: Some Notes for Hadith Dispersion in Social Media

Usman

Wazir

Nasir

2022

Insaniyat J. of Islam and Humanities

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

In Islam, the fabricated hadith is the least acknowledged hadith. The scholars unanimously reject this hadith and forbid its recitation without identifying its status. Fabricated hadith’s core perversion is its justification for the Prophet Muhammad’s assassination (PBUH). Falsification of hadith has harmed numerous facets of life, including faith, religious legislation, and acts of devotion. Additionally, the number of false hadiths is growing daily. This chilling reality has become a concern due to the widespread dissemination of such hadiths through modern technology. The dissemination of falsified hadiths via social media has emerged as a new issue that new-generation Muslims must take seriously, particularly individual awareness, knowledge, ethics, and morals.This paper will emphasize the hadith’s history and falsification aspects, assess its dispersion tendencies using more advanced media, and recommend many tips for preventing further dissemination. Using a qualitative method, this study found several guidelines to ensure the dispersion of fabricated hadith is handled properly, such as not believing in anything quickly, ensuring authenticity before sharing, and providing advice to admit mistakes in spreading the fabricated hadith. In this regard, we encourage academic scholars to conduct research on fabricated hadiths in order to preserve the purity and authority of the Prophet’s hadiths as the second Islamic source for Muslims.

show abstract

Section: Results and Discussion The Fabricated Hadith: History And Di...mentioning

confidence: 99%

How to Deal with the Fabricated Hadith: Some Notes for Hadith Dispersion in Social Media

Usman

Wazir

Nasir

2022

Insaniyat J. of Islam and Humanities

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

show abstract

Academic Crime for Humanities: Some Notes on Logical Perception of Anti-Hadith Group Movement

Wazir

Usman

Salleh

2019

HSSR

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

Purpose of this study: This article discusses the basic principles that must be possessed by Muslim scholars to understand knowledge and its sources. The term ‘academic crime’ generally refers to the conduct of a few university lecturers, who violate the ethics and good practices of the teaching profession through the misappropriation of powers or by making false claims. However, academic crimes can also be classified as frauds in publications. Indeed, the ability to reason is one of the things that a person possesses. Nevertheless, it is not absolute, because the Quran and hadith are on the topmost. Methodology: This study uses the qualitative method and finds excessive rationality by the Anti-Hadith Group (AHG), leading them into a crime, i.e., rejection of the hadith as one of the sources of Islamic law. Findings: The revelation is believed to be true even though it contains metaphysics (al-ghaibiyyat) that cannot be logically explained. Furthermore, in rejecting hadith, the AHG often uses the contradictions between the hadith and the current perspective of life in modern times. Novelty of study: It is a very serious phenomenon and needs to be dealt with appropriately. This is because arguing rationally as advocated by those who reject the hadith seems very strong and effective in giving the illusion of hadith flaws to the humanity, while it is not so in reality.

show abstract

Rationality and Logic Castigation from the Western Scholarly Perspective Towards Allegations of Anti-Hadith Groups

Cited by 2 publications

References 0 publications

How to Deal with the Fabricated Hadith: Some Notes for Hadith Dispersion in Social Media

How to Deal with the Fabricated Hadith: Some Notes for Hadith Dispersion in Social Media

Academic Crime for Humanities: Some Notes on Logical Perception of Anti-Hadith Group Movement

Contact Info

Product

Resources

About