Reason in Kant and Hegel

Ferrarin, Alfredo

doi:10.1515/kantyb-2016-0001

“…Ferrarin (2015: 34–42) also acknowledges the tension between the organic and the constructive model – as well as between the respective metaphors. On this point see also Ferrarin (2016: 2–3).…”

Section: Notesmentioning

confidence: 89%

“…3See Ferrarin 2016: 12: ‘method is the design and plan of the whole, the scientific form that guides the organization of cognitions’.…”

Section: Notesmentioning

confidence: 99%

The Schematism of Reason from the Dialectic to the Architectonic

Filieri

2023

Kantian rev.

0

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

In The Architectonic of Reason Lea Ypi argues that Kant ultimately fails in his attempt at grounding the systematic unity of reason because of the lack of the practical domain of freedom in the first Critique. I aim to advance a more nuanced reading of Kant’s alleged failure by (1) distinguishing between the schematism of the ideas in the Appendix to the Transcendental Dialectic and the schematism of pure reason in the Architectonic. (2) I suggest that, while the practical domain of freedom is not established in the first Critique, the Canon and the Architectonic do account for its condition: the practical employment of reason and its unity with the theoretical. I point out that while (3) the schematism of the ideas accounts for the sole systematic arrangement of the understanding’s cognitions and the regulative role of the ideas and the ideal, in the Architectonic, (4) the schematism of pure reason instead bears more generally on systematicity as reason’s way of proceeding in framing its own unitary whole and the unity between its two lawful employments.

show abstract

“…Based on the ideas of Immanuel Kant, Karl Popper was able to develop a strongly cohesive system of thought, creating a systematic philosophy in the great tradition of the centrality of the subject. His primary concern would be to separate science from pseudoscience, upholding reason as an end in itself, an ethical duty of human beings to provide themselves with transcendental truth (Ferrarin, 2016). In this sense, critical rationalism can be seen as the rational action of seeking truth through argument and compromise; in the same sense, based on its premise that all knowledge is transient and falsifiable, critical rationalism enables a posture of openness to dialogue with different views (Popper, 1934(Popper, /2005Thomas, 2010).…”

Section: Literary Critiquementioning

confidence: 99%

De Kant a Popper: Razão e Racionalismo Crítico nos Estudos Organizacionais

Couto

¹

,

Saraiva

²

,

Carrieri

³

2021

Organ. Soc.

2

0

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

The objective of this essay is to revisit the theoretical construction of Critical Rationalism, starting from the philosophy of Kantian reason contained in the works Critique of pure reason and Critique of practical reason to discuss their respective influences over the work of Karl Popper. We aim, with this exercise, to shed light on the critical-rationalist approach in Organization Studies. Our argument is that Kantian thought has been conducive, on the one hand, to a negative philosophy that considers idealism prior notions and a priori knowledge fundamental to the creative conception of knowledge and, on the other hand, to a hypothetical-deductive science that seeks to bring us closer to truth through criticism. The basis of critical rationalism lies in the search for reason and transcendental truth. This is a call not only for the production of theories, but for dedication to test their validity – a problem that has not received much attention from researchers in the field of organization studies.

show abstract

“…One of Kant's great legacies was the possibility of approaching cognition from an idealistic standpoint, strictly based on a priori knowledge, negative reason and the ability to revise knowledge. Sir Karl Raimund Popper (1902Popper ( -1994 was one of the great heirs of Kant's critical thinking, and his ideas originated the philosophy of critical rationalism as we know it today (Chiappin, 2008;Ferrarin, 2016). In the penultimate section of this article, we will explore critical rationalism as a democratic attitude, marked by intellectual autonomy and modesty, as well as a necessary research approach to contemporary organizational studies -whose corpus is characterized by the large-scale production of justificationist studies (Thomas, 2010).…”

Section: Kant's Influence On Popper: Critical Rationalism In Organization Studiesmentioning

confidence: 99%

From Kant to Popper: Reason and Critical Rationalism in Organization Studies

Couto

¹

,

Saraiva

²

,

Carrieri

³

2021

Organ. Soc.

1

0

View full text Add to dashboard Cite

The objective of this essay is to revisit the theoretical construction of Critical Rationalism, starting from the philosophy of Kantian reason contained in the works Critique of pure reason and Critique of practical reason to discuss their respective influences over the work of Karl Popper. We aim, with this exercise, to shed light on the critical-rationalist approach in Organization Studies. Our argument is that Kantian thought has been conducive, on the one hand, to a negative philosophy that considers idealism prior notions and a priori knowledge fundamental to the creative conception of knowledge and, on the other hand, to a hypothetical-deductive science that seeks to bring us closer to truth through criticism. The basis of critical rationalism lies in the search for reason and transcendental truth. This is a call not only for the production of theories, but for dedication to test their validity – a problem that has not received much attention from researchers in the field of organization studies.

show abstract

Reason in Kant and Hegel

Cited by 4 publications

References 0 publications

The Schematism of Reason from the Dialectic to the Architectonic

The Schematism of Reason from the Dialectic to the Architectonic

De Kant a Popper: Razão e Racionalismo Crítico nos Estudos Organizacionais

From Kant to Popper: Reason and Critical Rationalism in Organization Studies

Contact Info

Product

Resources

About