Rebalancing the Euro Area: The Costs of Internal Devaluation

Abstract

This paper investigates the economic costs of rebalancing current account positions in the Euro area by means of internal devaluation. Internal devaluation relies on wage suppression the deficit countries. Based on an old Keynesian model we estimate a current account equation, a wage-Phillips curve and an Okun's Law equation. All estimations are carried out for a panel of twelve Euro area members. From the estimation results we calculate the output costs of reducing current account deficits. Greece, Ireland, Italy, Portugal and Spain (GIIPS) had, on average, current account deficits of 8.4% of GDP in 2007. To eliminate these current account deficits, a reduction of GPD by some 47% would be necessary. In principle there are two ways that trade imbalances could be resolved: deflationary adjustment in the deficit countries or inflationary adjustment in the surplus countries. Presently, the burden of adjustment is exclusively on the deficit countries. Our results indicate that the economic costs of this adjustment to those countries are equivalent to the output loss of the Great Depression. An adjustment of the surplus countries would increase growth and it would come with higher inflation, but it would allow rebalancing without a Great Depression in parts of Europe.

Neoliberal growth models, monetary union and the Euro crisis. A post-Keynesian perspective

“…Europe now faces several challenges: It has to stimulate demand, re-balance its trade flows and relative prices and it has to deal with high private and public debt. In principle the cost imbalances can be dealt with by inflationary adjustment (that is adjustment in the surplus countries to increase prices and output) or by deflationary adjustment in the deficit countries (Stockhammer and Sotiropoulos 2014). The latter is presently being pursued under the name of 'internal devaluation'.…”

The legacy of a fractured Eurozone: The Greek Dra(ch)ma

“…Every time someone hoards currency, by definition, its lack of circulation deprives other people of being able to perform transactions. The more sophisticated forms of complementary currency of the 1930s included a circulation incentive feature recommended by Silvio Gesell 16 .…”

“…Most notably, that this is one region of the world where 'rules' have triumphed over even mainstream economic pragmatism (see Stockhammer and Sotiropoulos, 2014), forcing to pointless cuts in government spending. With reference to the world economy, both Summers (2013, ibid) and Krugman (2013, ibid) are adamants that what is needed is increased spending of all kinds to get the economies moving again, initially through expanded government expenditure, but with the object of jump-starting private investment spending.…”

The performativity of potential output: pro-cyclicality and path dependency in coordinating European fiscal policies

“…Lane, 2012;Sapir et al, 2014) finds its essential roots in the build-up of severe macroeconomic imbalances (e.g. Stockhammer & Sotiropoulos, 2014) in conjunction with the loss of monetary sovereignty, which constrains the ability of EMU member countries to counteract crisis dynamics (de Grauwe, 2012). The emerging fragilities of individual EZ countries during the pre-crisis years were fueled by credit-led economic growth and large capital flows from EZ 'core countries' like Germany, France and the Netherlands to 'periphery countries' such as Spain, Ireland, Portugal and Greece (e.g.…”