[FeFe]
hydrogenases are efficient catalysts for interconverting
hydrogen with protons and electrons, whose catalytic mechanism remains
a subject of controversy. Their active site, the H‑cluster,
is composed of a [4Fe–4S] subcluster ([4Fe–4S]H) covalently attached to a [2Fe] subcluster ([2Fe]H).
The two subclusters are strongly redox-coupled, and proton-coupled
electron transfer (PCET) within the H-cluster is thought to be essential
for catalytic activity. Additionally, proton-coupled reduction of
[4Fe–4S]H has been proposed. Here, we investigated
the pH dependence of the redox behavior of [4Fe–4S]H using infrared (IR) spectroelectrochemistry with two different [FeFe]
hydrogenases: CrHydA1 from Chlamydomonas
reinhardtii and CpHydA1 from Clostridium pasteurianum. Contrary to previous reports,
we find that, under our experimental conditions, the redox potential
of [4Fe–4S]H is independent of pH around physiological
values for both enzymes. We also found redox anticooperativity behavior
between [4Fe–4S]H and the accessory [4Fe–4S]
clusters (F-clusters) in CpHydA1, which tunes catalysis
at the active site. Taken together, these results indicate that the
catalytic cycle of [FeFe] hydrogenases likely does not involve protonation
at or near [4Fe–4S]H, and instead, favors a model
in which protonation of [2Fe]H drives catalysis. Our findings
shed new light on the catalytic mechanism of [FeFe] hydrogenases and
highlight the importance of the F-clusters in fine-tuning catalysis.