Defensive sound production is widespread and highly diverse among insects, yet the specific functions and factors affecting its evolution are poorly understood. In this thesis, I have two overarching objectives. 1) I conduct a literature review on insect defence sounds and show that sounds have been reported in 12 insect orders with an enormous variety of sound-producing mechanisms, acoustic features, and proposed functions. Based on my review, I pose hypotheses and predictions to explain the diversity and evolution of sonic defences. 2) I study caterpillars of the Superfamily Bombycoidea (silk and hawk moths) to test some of these hypotheses using experimental and phylogenetic comparative methods. I do this in three stages. First, I document defensive responses of 44 species (33 previously untested), bringing the total number of tested Bombycoidea species in our database to 97. I show that 34/97 produce defence sounds. Second, I characterize different sound-producing mechanisms (clicking, chirping, whistling, and vocalizing), contributing new acoustic data for 13 previously unreported sound producers. Third, I use this information to develop and test hypotheses on how defence sounds evolved and function in Bombycoidea by mapping sound production onto a phylogeny that I constructed.Interestingly, the different sound-producing mechanisms occur in multiple distantly related groups, suggesting convergent evolution; yet, closely related species can differ in their soundproducing abilities or mechanisms. These results suggest there are important selective pressures for evolving defence sounds, and that these pressures could vary to produce different types of sounds. Using phylogenetic comparative methods, I explore possible factors to explain "why sound". Two results stand out: body size (based on head capsules) and trade-offs with defensive secretions. I also found support for the hypothesis that short sounds (i.e., clicking and chirping) are aposematic in function because they correlate to the presence of chemical defences. Overall, iii this research offers valuable contributions to the study of insect defence sounds: I provide the first comprehensive review of this topic, establish a model system by characterizing sonic defences (and other responses) in Bombycoidea caterpillars, and provide support for key hypotheses on the evolutionary origins, selective pressures, and functions of these sounds.iv
AcknowledgementsFirst and foremost, I would like to thank Jayne for her continuous guidance and support over the years. From her prompt response to my first inquiry about grad school, to encouraging me to fast-track to the PhD program, and to (finally!) getting this tome complete, Jayne has been hands-down the greatest supervisor I could have asked for. Not only has Jayne been an awesome supervisor, but she has also been instrumental in helping me pursue teaching as a career, and has been there to celebrate many of my major life events. I'd also like to thank the other two key members of my committee: Myron Smith and Tom...