Rad51 can promote extensive strand exchange in vitro in the absence of ATP hydrolysis, and the Rad51-K191R mutant protein, which can bind but poorly hydrolyze ATP, also promotes strand exchange. A haploid strain expressing the rad51-K191R allele showed an equivalent sensitivity at low doses of ionizing radiation to rad51-K191A or rad51 null mutants and was defective in spontaneous and double-strand break-induced mitotic recombination. However, the rad51-K191R/rad51-K191R diploid sporulated and the haploid spores showed high viability, indicating no apparent defect in meiotic recombination. The DNA repair defect caused by the rad51-K191R allele was suppressed in diploids and by mating-type heterozygosity in haploids. RAD54 expressed from a high-copy-number plasmid also suppressed the ␥-ray sensitivity of rad51-K191R haploids. The suppression by mating-type heterozygosity of the DNA repair defect conferred by the rad51-K191R allele could occur by elevated expression of factors that act to stabilize, or promote catalysis, by the partially functional Rad51-K191R protein.The RAD51 gene encodes a structural and functional homologue of the Escherichia coli RecA protein (1, 4, 37). Rad51 exhibits ATP-dependent binding to single-stranded DNA and a weak ATPase activity (37, 41). Strand exchange by Rad51 requires a nucleotide cofactor but can occur in the presence of the nonhydrolyzable ATP analogs, AMP-PNP and ATP␥S (41,43). This observation has raised the issue of the role of ATP hydrolysis in Rad51-mediated recombination. The invariant lysine residue within the Walker A motif of Rad51 has been substituted with arginine or alanine to generate mutants able to bind but not hydrolyze ATP (Rad51-K191R), or unable to bind ATP (Rad51-K191A). The Rad51-K191R mutant protein was shown to promote strand exchange in vitro when the concentration of the mutant protein was about four times higher than normally used for the wild-type protein, but the Rad51-K191A protein was completely defective for DNA binding and strand exchange (43). The rad51-K191A allele expressed from the native promoter on a low-copy-number plasmid, or expressed from a strong constitutive promoter, was unable to complement the methyl methanesulfonate sensitivity or recombination defects of a rad51⌬ strain (37, 43). However, the rad51-K191R allele showed partial complementation of the DNA repair and recombination defects of the rad51⌬ strain when expressed from a low-copy-number plasmid (37) and full complementation when overexpressed (43). Thus, it appears that the requirement for ATP hydrolysis can be circumvented when the intracellular concentration of Rad51-K191R is elevated. In contrast, binding and hydrolysis of ATP are critical for RecA function in vivo, even though extensive strand exchange occurs in vitro in the absence of ATP hydrolysis (25,32).Deletion of RAD51 in vertebrates results in cell inviability and early embryonic lethality in mice (23,44). A RAD51 conditional cell line has been made by deleting both copies of RAD51 in DT40 chicken cells in the...