Relationship Marketing in Emerging Economies: Some Lessons for the Future

Abstract

Relationship marketing as a philosophy and a set of practices is now widely accepted by both academics and practitioners. At the centre of the relationship marketing paradigm is the notion that making the most out of existing clients is essential for long-term profitability. Retaining clients by developing relationships with them is crucial to establishing and maintaining a competitive advantage in the market. But, moving away from an analysis of needs to an analysis of the customer, from management of the transaction to management of the relationship marks a fundamental shift which positions relationship marketing as a double innovation: conceptual innovation (it has evolved into an entirely new and separate concept) and organizational innovation (it imposes transformation on organizations that are not limited to the marketing function but require the participation of all components of the firm). But, perceptions on what exactly constitutes relationship marketing may differ in various cultural settings.Indeed, the theoretical domains that relationship marketing has traditionally drawn upon have been Western theories developed in economics, psychology, and management. Having largely exhausted these sources, it is now perhaps time to look more widely and consider less traditional paradigms from a broader range of cultures. The author suggests looking at Eastern cultures where relationships have provided the foundations for business activity for thousands of years.This article is an initial attempt to bridge the gap in existing literature as no adequate conceptual framework exists as yet. It aims to contribute to the knowledge of the reasons for the emergence of relationship marketing in Western economies and makes a brief comparison of the study of relationships in Western and Eastern literature so as to identify how culturally-based relationships are formed. In particular, the focus is on the Chinese complex concept of guanxi (loosely translated as 'connections' though 'relationships' might be better) and its importance in relationship development. This framework is the starting point for a set of criteria to be taken into account before transferring relationship marketing in emerging economies.In conclusion, this exploratory paper highlights the following:Theory transgresses economies whether they are emerging or not. Marketing has always studied relationships between institutions (B2B) and between institutions and customers (B2C). The basic rules of marketing, therefore, remain the same whatever the economy. What changes is the context.The environment is and remains multi-cultural. In that sense, the dangers of ethnocentrism must be avoided and, on the contrary, the phenomena of acculturation and local appropriation must be embraced. To be successfully implemented, relationship marketing should reflect the value system of the population to which it is targeted.

Online shopping experience in an emerging e‐retailing market: Towards a conceptual model

“…We situate our research within an emerging marketing context due to paucity of research in emerging markets and dominance of studies published in developed markets. This is surprising given that emerging markets differ from developed markets in terms of economic and sociocultural realities (Flambard‐Ruaud, ). Tahmouresi, Bender, Schmitz, Baleshzar, and Tuschen‐Caffier () demonstrated that emotions differ across cultures and between developed and developing countries.…”

Estabelecendo Relacionamentos com Empresas Chinesas: O Papel do Guanxi no Desenvolvimento da Confiança de um Projeto Colaborativo

“…Também, se refere ao uso de um subconjunto de relações que operam de acordo com normas de reciprocidade podendo apresentar uma conotação negativa quando relacionado ao suborno e à corrupção. Nesse contexto, o guanxi ou guanxixue representa o uso de conexões pessoais para burlar regulamentos, leis ou normas, e assim, obter benefícios políticos e/ou econômicos (GUTHRIE, 1998;FLAMBARD-RUAUD, 2005;LEE & DAWES, 2005;LORD, 2007).…”

“…A governança interorganizacional utiliza-se de mecanismos que influenciam os custos de transação e fornecem incentivos para as iniciativas de criação de valor, tais como o investimento em ativos específicos à relação, a partilha de conhecimentos ou a combinação de recursos estratégicos complementares (DYER & SINGH, 1998). Ao analisar díades formadas por empresas de países diferentes, deve-se considerar não somente o estabelecimento e a configuração dos mecanismos de governança que operam para garantir o funcionamento contínuo das parcerias (HAHN & GOLD, 2014), mas também a importância relativa dos atributos que compõem o relacionamento, valorados e construídos de modo diferente em diversas partes do mundo (FLAMBARD-RUAUD, 2005). Nesse contexto, os RIOs que envolvem empresas chinesas requerem atenção especial, principalmente no que se refere ao entendimento da construção da confiança e sua inter-relação com o guanxi -entendido como a relação entre várias partes que cooperam juntas e se apoiam umas às outras (YEN & ABOSAG, 2016).…”

Moderating impact of tourism relationship management dimensions on tourism service quality, tourist satisfaction and destination loyalty

“…Hsu et al (2008) observed preserving loyalty of established customer as a crucial contributor to the achievement and profitability of business. Accordingly, the main reason why researchers should consider revisit intention is the fact that "globalization of markets, competitive pressure, brand multiplication and, above all, the ever-changing lifestyles and consumer behavior have forced companies to develop strategies to keep their clients and create consumer loyalty programs" (Flambard-Ruaud, 2005), particularly in tourism industry.…”