Reliability of Smartphone Pulse Oximetry in Subjects at Risk for Hypoxemia

Abstract

BACKGROUND: Pulse oximeters are used to measure S pO 2 and heart rate. These devices are either standalone machines or integrated into physiologic monitoring systems. Some smartphones now have pulse oximetry capabilities. Because it is possible that some patients might utilize this technology, we sought to assess the accuracy and usability of smartphone pulse oximeters. METHODS: This was a prospective, observational study that involved noninvasive measurements of S pO 2 and heart rate with 3 devices: Masimo Radical-7, Kenek Edge with the Apple iPhone 6S, and the Samsung S8 smartphone. Ambulatory adult patients visiting our institution's pulmonary function lab for a 6-min walk test were eligible to participate in the study. Pretest and posttest results for each subject were obtained simultaneously using all 3 devices. All results were analyzed with the Spearman rho correlation test, and Bland-Altman plots were used to assess the agreement of measures between the devices. RESULTS: Forty-seven subjects were enrolled in the study, with pulmonary hypertension (30%) and COPD (23%) being the 2 major diagnoses. The mean 6 SD difference between the Masimo and Apple devices for pretest S pO 2 was 2.3 6 2.4%, and the difference for posttest S pO 2 was 2.1 6 3.9%. The mean difference between the Masimo and Samsung devices for pretest S pO 2 was 3.2 6 2.8%, and the difference for posttest S pO 2 was 2.4 6 3.5%. The number of subjects who were unable to obtain S pO 2 was higher with the Samsung device than with the Apple device in both pretest (14 of 47 vs 3 of 47) and posttest (17 of 47 vs 5 of 47). In contrast, the Masimo device was able to measure S pO 2 in all subjects. CONCLUSIONS: Smartphone pulse oximeters were unreliable compared to a hospital pulse oximeter. Further research is needed with evolving technology to better understand smartphone pulse oximetry. (ClinicalTrials.gov registration NCT03534271.

Accuracy of Samsung Smartphone Integrated Pulse Oximetry Meets Full FDA Clearance Standards for Clinical Use

“…22 Modi et al conducted 6 minute walk pre- and post-oximetry testing to perform a comparison of a Massimo-radical7 device, a clip Kenek sensor connected to an iPhone, and a Samsung Galaxy 8. 23 They reported a correlation between SpO 2 measurements (r= 0.62 - 0.72, p<0.001) and provided values from 28 out of 47 participants on a Bland Altman analysis that used an average of the SpO 2 obtained by the FDA approved Massimo-radical7 reference device and the smartphone readings as ‘true’ SpO 2 , making this data difficult to evaluate. Most recently, Browne et al reported findings from clinical studies on 320 participants that utilized a repeated measure, nested factorial design to evaluate the accuracy and precision of a smartphone model, containing Maxim Integrated biosensors and App in comparison to Welch Allyn reference units.…”

Diagnostic Accuracy of Oxygen Desaturation Index for Sleep-Disordered Breathing in Patients With Diabetes

“…Thus, a simple overnight screening and everyday monitoring could become possible. However, these devices are often not certified to give medical accurate information on oxygen saturation (36). Signal quality, signal treatment, and averaging over several pulses may vary and differ largely compared to oximetry integrated in a polysomnography as used here.…”

Wearable, Multimodal, Biosignal Acquisition System for Potential Critical and Emergency Applications

“…Recently, oxygen saturation (SpO 2 ) combined with ECG was used to detect stenosis or occlusion of an arteriovenous fistula/graft, the progression of arteriosclerosis, and arrhythmia [ 25 ]. SpO 2 is a measure of the amount of oxygen-carrying hemoglobin in the blood relative to the amount of hemoglobin not carrying oxygen [ 26 – 29 ]. The body requires a certain level of oxygen in the blood to function efficiently [ 26 , 28 , 30 ].…”

“…SpO 2 is a measure of the amount of oxygen-carrying hemoglobin in the blood relative to the amount of hemoglobin not carrying oxygen [ 26 – 29 ]. The body requires a certain level of oxygen in the blood to function efficiently [ 26 , 28 , 30 ]. In fact, very low levels of SpO 2 can result in severe symptoms [ 26 ].…”

“…The body requires a certain level of oxygen in the blood to function efficiently [ 26 , 28 , 30 ]. In fact, very low levels of SpO 2 can result in severe symptoms [ 26 ]. An ECG conditioning circuit is employed to examine the measured ECG signal.…”