Representativeness and face-ism: Gender bias in image search

Abstract

Implicit and explicit gender biases in media representations of individuals have long existed. Women are less likely to be represented in gender-neutral media content (representation bias), and their face-to-body ratio in images is often lower (face-ism bias). In this article, we look at representativeness and face-ism in search engine image results. We systematically queried four search engines (Google, Bing, Baidu, Yandex) from three locations, using two browsers and in two waves, with gender-neutral (person, intelligent person) and gendered (woman, intelligent woman, man, intelligent man) terminology, accessing the top 100 image results. We employed automatic identification for the individual’s gender expression (female/male) and the calculation of the face-to-body ratio of individuals depicted. We find that, as in other forms of media, search engine images perpetuate biases to the detriment of women, confirming the existence of the representation and face-ism biases. In-depth algorithmic debiasing with a specific focus on gender bias is overdue.

Memory, counter-memory and denialism: How search engines circulate information about the Holodomor-related memory wars

“…This auditing approach uses virtual agents (i.e. software simulating user behavior, such as scrolling webpages) to generate system inputs and then record the resulting outputs (Ulloa et al, 2022b). In the context of search engine research, it allows controlling for personalization (Hannak et al, 2013) and randomization (Makhortykh et al, 2020) factors.…”

Googling Politics? The Computational Identification of Political and News-related Searches from Web Browser Histories

“…Furthermore, search results can impact voter preferences (Epstein & Robertson, 2015) and are widely trusted (Dutton et al, 2017;Pan et al, 2007;. However, public and academic concerns about the impact of search engines on the representation of information (Pradel, 2020;Ulloa et al, 2022;, the spread of misinformation (Urman, Makhortykh, Ulloa, & Kulshrestha, 2021) and the creation of filter bubbles (Pariser, 2011), call into question the extent to which this trust is justified. These concerns become more pressing given developments set to revolutionise information consumption, like AI-generated answers on Google's search result page (Google, 2023).…”