Research about inclusive education: Are the scope, reach and limits empirical and methodological and/or conceptual and evaluative?

Abstract

This paper argues for a broader conception about research into inclusive education, one that extends beyond a focus on empirical factors associated with inclusive education and the effects of inclusive education. It starts with a recent summary of international research into the effects of inclusive education on students with SEN/disabilities and those without. On the basis of this review, it examines a model showing the complexity of factors involved in asking questions about the effects of inclusive education. This complexity reflects the ambiguity and complexity of inclusive education, which is discussed in terms of varied contemporary positions about inclusive education. The analysis illustrates how there has been more focus on thin concepts of inclusion (as setting placement or in general terms) rather than its normative and value basis, which reflects a thick concept of inclusion. The paper concludes by illustrating with the use of a version of the capability approach how there are value tensions implicit in inclusion about difference and about personal vs. public choice. This requires value clarification and some settlement about the balance of values, which is where deliberative democratic principles and processes have a crucial role. The proposed answer to the paper’s question about the scope, reach and limits of research in inclusive education is that such research involves both empirical, methodological, and evaluative matters. Educational research about inclusive education is not just empirical, it also involves value and norm clarification, a process which has been too often ignored.

From barriers to boosters: initial teacher education for inclusive science education

“…PSTs often feel lost and receive impractical recommendations that contradicts a broad understanding of inclusion. We argued that an adequate approach to initial science teacher education must be based on inclusive values that have to be conveyed as a basis (Norwich, 2022), and we drew on the value-based approach of Florian (2021) here. We identified barriers and boosters toward inclusion in initial science teacher education.…”

“…Limiting it to disability is not productive. Therefore, this paper adopts a reflective understanding of inclusion that views inclusion as a normatively shaped reflection process, adapting a value based, "thick" concept (Norwich, 2022) of inclusion:…”

Fair funding for pupils with special educational needs and disability in England?

“…This study has involved quantitative desktop analysis of the relationship between different variables, in particular the use of specialist provision, to explore the impact on the allocation of the HNB of the NFF. However, a major limitation to this research is that it focuses on the ‘thin’ concepts of inclusion (as setting placement or in general terms) rather than its normative and value basis, which reflects the ‘thick’ concept of inclusion (Norwich, 2022). It is particularly important to acknowledge the importance of LA policies regarding inclusion.…”

“…The political agendas of many countries promote reforms aimed at developing more inclusive education systems (Azorin & Ainscow, 2020). There has been much debate over the years about the meaning, value and funding of inclusion (e.g., Banks et al., 2023; Gordon‐Gould & Hornby, 2023; Gray, 2010; Lindsay, 2011; Norwich, 2022). The present government's SEND and AP Improvement Plan (Gov.…”

Sociology and Contemporary Education Social Observation in Cultural Fabric and Garment Oversight in Makeni, Bombali District, Northern Sierra Leone

“…Administered social substantiality in pedagogical education also bolsters students' capability to practice and consolidate what they have acquired in the classroom (Kubik, 2021). ConsiderablgMalafantis, 2022;Teo & Pua, 2021;Livingston-Galloway, 2021;Norwich, 2022;Madhesh, 2023;Kurowski et al, 2022;Izghar and Ilter, 2022;Simsek and Kilcan, 2019;Leijen et al, 2021;Roldan, 2021).…”