Researching young children’s perception of food in Irish pre-schools: An ethical dilemma

Abstract

Poor nutrition habits have been reported in the childcare setting. While the literature advocates the need to carry out ‘Voice of the Child’ research, few studies have explored this methodology with regard to children and food, in particular in the pre-school setting. This article aims to outline the ethical issues raised by a research ethics committee and to discuss the impact of these issues on a study that hoped to determine the food perceptions of children (aged three to four years) within an ongoing nutrition and lifestyle pre-school project in Ireland. Ethical approval was granted for this study but only upon the clarification of two aspects: that only hedonic symbols previously used in the literature could be included in the study; and that parental consent be obtained from both parents of each child. Children were shown food pictures and asked to use the hedonic symbols to answer questions posed to them on the food. Owing to the ethical constraints imposed by the requirement for two-parent consent, seven children, from a potential sample of 85, were eligible to partake in the study. These children did not seem to understand the hedonic symbols recommended for use by the ethics committee, therefore preventing the collection of in-depth qualitative data. The ethical constraints placed on this study impacted on both its design and its methodology and are discussed in relation to national and international ethical guidance and legislation. Future research with children regarding food choice must balance the need for strict ethical standards with the need to explore children’s views on this subject.

Editorial: Could informed consent be harmful? – the problem of the nocebo effect

“…This issue contains several articles providing a perspective on the ethics of researching with children as well as an interesting topics piece on the plan to open up clinical records for ‘real-time’ research. Charlotte Johnston Molloy et al focus on the ethical and regulatory challenges in researching the perception of food of young children (Molloy et al, 2012). We have a narrative written by such a young participant in research, a 10-year-old who participated in a National Diet Survey and reflects on her experience (Edwards and Edwards, 2012).…”

“…Charlotte Johnston Molloy et al focus on the ethical and regulatory challenges in researching the perception of food of young children (Molloy et al, 2012). We have a narrative written by such a young participant in research, a 10-year-old who participated in a National Diet Survey and reflects on her experience (Edwards and Edwards, 2012).…”