Revisiting the Role of Cultural Capital in East Asian Educational Systems

Abstract

The concept of cultural capital has proved invaluable in understanding educational systems in Western countries, and recent work seeks to extend those insights to the diverse educational systems of other geographic regions. We explored cultural capital in South Korea by investigating the relationships among family socioeconomic status (SES), cultural capital, and children's academic achievement using data from the 2000 Programme for International Student Assessment. South Korea was compared with Japan, France, and the United States to understand how institutional features of South Korean education shape the role of cultural capital in academic success. Results showed that family SES had a positive effect on both parental objectified cultural capital and children's embodied cultural capital in South Korea, consistent with evidence from the other countries. Moreover, parental objectified cultural capital had a positive effect on children's academic achievement in South Korea. In contrast to other countries, however, children's embodied cultural capital had a negative effect on academic achievement in South Korea controlling for the other variables. We highlighted several institutional features of South Korean education including a standardized curriculum, extreme focus on test preparation, and extensive shadow education, which may combine to suppress the effect of children's embodied cultural capital on academic achievement.

How Korean Language Arts Teachers Adopt and Adapt Open Educational Resources: A Study of Teachers’ and Students’ Perspectives

“…As a result, many organizations and leaders, including then-U.S. President Obama, have praised Korea for its successful educational system. A considerable amount of educational studies have also investigated Korean educational systems (e.g., Bozkurt, 2014;Byun, Schofer, & Kim, 2012;Cheung, Sit, Soh, Ieong, & Mak, 2014;Sánchez, Salinas, & Harris, 2011).…”

Can children break the cycle of disadvantage? Structure and agency in the transmission of education across generations

“…There are no multicollinearity issues among the central independent variables and the covariates (variance inflation factor values < 2.5). Multilevel modeling is a standard method to analyze hierarchically structured data and has been applied in numerous studies based on PISA and other large-scale surveys (e.g., Byun et al 2012;Le Donné 2014;Schlicht et al 2010). Given that the PISA surveys provide cross-sectional data, some uncertainty remains as to the causal effects of the independent variables on students' educational performance.…”

Women rising as half of the sky? An empirical study on women from the one-child generation and their higher education participation in contemporary China

“…The concepts of embodied and objective cultural capital are extended to East Asian contexts such as Japan and South Korea to measure the impact of family activities, cultural acquisition (embodied capital) and cultural possessions (objectified capital) on children's academic achievement and aspirations (Byun et al 2012;Yamamoto and Brinton 2010). However, the Chinese context raises the question about how to understand the impact of parental cultural capital and socioeconomic status on their daughters' aspirations and expectations with these particular demographic characteristics.…”