Nonclassical and classical osmium polyhydrides containing the diphosphine 9,9-dimethyl-4,5-bis(diisopropylphosphino)xanthene (xant(PPr)), coordinated in κ-mer, κ-fac, and κ-P,P fashions, have been isolated during the cyclic formation of H by means of the sequential addition of H and H or H and H to the classical trihydride OsHCl{xant(PPr)} (1). This complex adds H to form the compressed dihydride dihydrogen complex [OsCl(H···H)(η-H){xant(PPr)}] (2). Under argon, cation 2 loses H and the resulting unsaturated fragment dimerizes to give [(Os(H···H){xant(PPr)})(μ-Cl)] (3). During the transformation the phosphine changes its coordination mode from mer to fac. The benzofuran counterpart of 1, OsHCl{dbf(PPr)} (4; dbf(PPr) = 4,6-bis(diisopropylphosphino)dibenzofuran), also adds H to afford the benzofuran counterpart of 2, [OsCl(H···H)(η-H){xant(PPr)}] (5), which in contrast to the latter is stable and does not dimerize. Acetonitrile breaks the chloride bridge of 3 to form the dihydrogen [OsCl(η-H)(CHCN){xant(PPr)}] (6), regenerating the mer coordination of the diphosphine. The hydride ion also breaks the chloride bridge of 3. The addition of KH to 3 leads to 1, closing a cycle for the formation of H. Complex 1 reacts with a second hydride ion to give OsH{xant(PPr)} (7) as consequence of the displacement of the chloride. Similarly to the latter, the oxygen atom of the mer-coordinated diphosphine of 7 has a tendency to be displaced by the hydride ion. Thus, the addition of KH to 7 yields [OsH{xant(PPr)}] (8), containing a κ-P,P-diphosphine. Complex 8 is easily protonated to afford OsH{xant(PPr)} (9), which releases H to regenerate 7, closing a second cycle for the formation of molecular hydrogen.