Engineering enzymes capable of modes of activation unprecedented in nature will increase the range of industrially important molecules that can be synthesized through biocatalysis. However, low activity for a new function is often a limitation in adopting enzymes for preparative scale synthesis, reaction with demanding substrates, or when a natural substrate is also present. By mutating the proximal ligand and other key active site residues of the cytochrome P450 from Bacillus megaterium (P450-BM3), we have engineered a highly active His-ligated variant of P450-BM3, BM3-Hstar, that can be employed for the enantioselective synthesis of the levomilnacipran core. This enzyme catalyzesthe cyclopropanation of N,N-diethyl-2-phenylacrylamide (1) with an estimated initial rate of over 1000 turnovers per minute and can be used under an aerobic environment. Cyclopropanation activity is highly dependent on the electronics of the P450 proximal ligand, which can be used to tune this non-natural enzyme activity.