Role of community health service programs in navigating the medical ethical slippery slope—a 10-year retrospective study among medical students from southern China

Abstract

Background For promoting autonomous learning motivation, the learning effect of community-oriented service is beneficial, because through community participation and service, students can transfer their implicit cognition of ethics into explicit cognition, leading to the cultivation of a sympathetic partnership between the community and medical students. Despite the proven benefits of medical students’ community health service (CHS) in Western countries, CHS programs designed for medical students are not well established in mainland China, and their effects on medical students’ ethical cognition are largely unknown. This study evaluated the effects of CHS programs on the ethical cognition of medical students. Methods A cross-sectional study was conducted on third- and fourth-year medical students and graduates working at Shantou University Medical College by using a self-administered anonymous questionnaire. Through interviews, we applied a thematic approach to analyze the responses of the participating students. The questionnaire adopted in this study was revised based on a review of the literature on medical ethics in medical students and on the CHS environment in China. The reviewed questionnaires included an evaluation questionnaire on cultivating medical ethics in a CHS context, and questionnaires used to explore the cultivation and transformation of medical ethics in medical students during the preclinical period. Results A total of 361 (54.4%) undergraduate medical students and 302 (45.6%) graduates participated in this survey. Significant differences were observed in self-evaluation of the cognitive development of ethics between those who had participated in CHS programs 1–5 times and those who had participated > 6 times. The successful identification of accepting money from the patients under the table as unethical behavior significantly differed ( p = .031) among the graduates but not ( p = .567) among the undergraduate students. The participants expressed the positive impact of CHS programs on their self-development. Conclusion CHS programs can be widely applied in medical education in China. This educational strategy, which supports medical professionalism and incorporates humanitarian behavior as a complement to learning, should be encouraged and promoted nationally.

Time use in out-of-class activities and its association with self-efficacy and perceived stress: data from second-year medical students in China

“…Understanding medical students' time use before they get even busier with clinical studies may better predict how well they would perform in clinical practice. For example, research shows that participating in volunteering activities in preclerkship years had a prevention effect, which can deter unethical behaviors among medical students in clinical practice [36]. Of particular note is that Chinese medical students were typically admitted to medical school immediately after high school, so this study can provide practical evidence for countries that offer similar undergraduate medical programs, such as the UK, Australia, and Japan [37].…”