“…The liquid treatment, UST-L, produces excellent refinement when the alloy contains more potent substrates and solute (Atamanenko et al, 2010;Wang et al, 2017c;Nagasivamuni et al, 2019a). The solidification treatment UST-S, on the other hand, can produce refinement in pure metals (Wang et al, 2017d;Nagasivamuni et al, 2018) and dilute alloys (Wang et al, 2014(Wang et al, , 2016a(Wang et al, , 2017bSrivastava et al, 2017) without potent substrates.…”