Roots of social enterprise: entrepreneurial philanthropy, England 1600-1908

Abstract

Purpose Insights into the roots of social enterprise from before the term was adopted are provided by examining histories of charitable service and comparing current understandings of social enterprise. Social enterprise models of welfare provision are evidenced from the seventeenth century onwards. Persistent themes are identified that provide insights for current practice and understanding. Design/methodology/approach This historiography examines interpretations from 1905 to the present day of examples of welfare provision between two watershed points: 1600, just prior to the Poor Laws and 1908, when the Old Age Pensions Act shifted emphasis in public sector provision. Findings Activities that would nowadays be termed social enterprise are evidenced in histories of charitable philanthropy covering each century since 1600. Prevailing attitudes uncritically demarcated deserving and undeserving poor. Histories contributed to a heroic narrative of social entrepreneurs, describing activities dependent on well-networked, politically active individuals that rarely continued beyond their involvement. The political environment was recognised to influence the types of organisations, governance and resourcing. Research limitations/implications The historiography takes examples from three centuries between 1600 and1908 but is not comprehensive. Recurrent themes are identified for further research. Originality/value Social enterprise is a twenty-first-century label but not a new phenomenon. Identification of prevailing themes provides insights for the understanding of social enterprises in the twenty-first century.

Hidden aspects of social entrepreneurs’ life: a content analysis

“…Individuals, those who know their traditions and beliefs, and capable of knowing the drawback of their society, seeks these drawbacks as a business opportunity (Zahra et al, 2009). Moreover, another inspiration factor for the social entrepreneurs is the belief in divine power, which is encouraging social entrepreneurs to enhance his or her community (MacDonald & Howorth, 2018;Omorede, 2014;Thompson, 2008).…”

Exploring the role of narrative in social enterprise and social innovation

“…Directly addressing the figure of the "heroic individualist entrepreneur", which lingered in the social entrepreneurship narrative long before social enterprise became a labelled activity in the 21st century (MacDonald and Howorth, 2018), other authors note that social entrepreneurs are, on the whole, much more concerned with collective effort and teamwork than they are with their own careers, journeys and self-promotion; they argue that this indicates some critical gaps between practitioner-level and sector-level narratives of social entrepreneurship (Parkinson and Howorth, 2008;Mody and Day, 2017;Jeong et al, 2020;SEJ 20,3 Cunningham et al, 2022) and champion a systems view on social innovation (Tanimoto, 2010).…”

Life Stories of Social and Environmental Entrepreneurs

“…It is worth adding that another inspirational factor for social entrepreneurs was the belief in divine power, which encouraged social entrepreneurs to improve their community (MacDonald & Howorth, 2018). In addition to these, there are also environmental, demographic, personal, and psychological factors that motivated individuals to become social entrepreneurs.…”