Crystals of TETROL [(+)-(2R,3R)-1,1-4,4-tetraphenylbutane-1,2,3,4-tetraol], when grown from four different cycloalkanones, namely cyclopentanone (5-ONE), cyclohexanone (6-ONE), cycloheptanone (7-ONE), and cyclooctanone (8-ONE), consistently produced 1:1 host/guest complexes. Thermoanalytical experiments revealed the relative thermal stabilities of these complexes to be in the order 6-ONE > 7-ONE > 8-ONE > 5-ONE. Subsequent binary guest/guest competition experiments correlated precisely with this selectivity order, and TETROL was observed to reliably favor 6-ONE, while 5-ONE was never preferred. This preference for 6-ONE was most significant when the other guest species was 5-or 8-ONE, and selectivity coefficients were calculated to be 7.2 and 5.6, respectively. Single-crystal X-ray diffraction analyses showed that each guest was retained in the crystals by means of, amongst others, a classical hydrogen bond with a TETROL alcohol moiety. Furthermore, the crystals with the more favored guests, 6-and 7-ONE, possessed greater densities than those with less preferred, 8and 5-ONE. Finally, upon analysis of the guest conformations, it was observed that they were enclathrated as their low-energy conformers. The selectivity of TETROL for 6-and 7-ONE and the improved thermal stability of the complexes containing these two guests are suggested to be a consequence of improved complementarity between molecules resulting in the greater densities witnessed for their crystals.