The involvement of planar carbocation intermediates is
generally
considered undesirable in asymmetric catalysis due to the difficulty
in gaining facial control and their intrinsic stability issues. Recently,
suitably designed chiral catalyst(s) have enabled a guided approach
of nucleophiles to one of the prochiral faces of carbocations affording
high enantiocontrol. Herein, we present the vital mechanistic insights
from our comprehensive density functional theory (B3LYP-D3) study
on a chiral Ir-phosphoramidite-catalyzed asymmetric reductive deoxygenation
of racemic tertiary α-substituted allenylic alcohols. The catalytic
transformation relies on the synergistic action of a phosphoramidite-modified
Ir catalyst and Bi(OTf)3, first leading to the formation
of an Ir-π-allenyl carbocation intermediate through a turn-over-determining
SN1 ionization, followed by a face-selective hydride transfer
from a Hantzsch ester analogue to yield an enantioenriched product.
Bi(OTf)3 was found to promote a significant number of ionic
interactions as well as noncovalent interactions (NCIs) with the catalyst
and the substrates (allenylic alcohol and Hantzsch ester), thus providing
access to a lower energy route as compared to the pathways devoid
of Bi(OTf)3. In the nucleophilic addition, the chiral induction
was found to depend on the number and efficacy of such key NCIs. The
curious case of reversal of enantioselectivity, when the α-substituent
of the allenyl alcohol is changed from methyl to cyclopropyl, was
identified to originate from a change in mechanism from an enantioconvergent
pathway (α-methyl) to a dynamic kinetic asymmetric transformation
(α-cyclopropyl). These molecular insights could lead to newer
strategies to tame tertiary carbocations in enantioselective reactions
using suitable combinations of catalysts and additives.