The Aquia aquifer (southern Maryland) contains a remarkably smooth Cl− profile (0.46–3.23 ppm) along its flow path. This is interpreted as a record of historic changes in the deposition of Cl− in this region. Those changes have been influenced by the rise and fall of sea level, which has altered the distance of the recharge region from the coastline by ∼200 km. The 36Cl concentration along the flow path is not as smooth as the Cl− profile. Historic variations in cosmogenic production, atmospheric transport, precipitation, and evapotranspiration all might have influenced 36Cl concentrations. A general similarity between the 36Cl and Cl− profiles suggests that changes in precipitation and evapotranspiration rates, which influence both tracers similarly, are particularly important. To reconcile 14C, 36Cl, and hydrologic data, we propose a two‐tier model for flow in the Aquia. Shallower portions of the aquifer (<60 m) were subjected to hydraulic gradients and flow rates approximately 5 times larger during the Pleistocene than modern, prepumping rates. At greater depths, flow rates were much slower and less variable; water in this region may be old enough to record some 36Cl decay.