“…Recent seismic studies of the shallow mantle underneath the Baja California Peninsula (Wang et al, 2009(Wang et al, , 2013Long, 2010;Zhang et al, 2007Zhang et al, , 2009Obrebski and Castro, 2008;Persaud et al, 2007) cause us to question the formation mechanics of shallow slab gaps and/or slab windows (Dickinson, 1997;Benoit et al, 2002;Calmus et al, 2003Calmus et al, , 2011Ferrari, 2004;Pallares et al, 2008). For example, seismic tomography in the Gulf of California clearly shows that there is no tensional gash beneath southcentral Baja California (Wang et al, 2009(Wang et al, , 2013Zhang et al, 2007Zhang et al, , 2009.…”