Setting Requirements for a Dashboard to Inform Portuguese Decision-Makers About Environment Health in an Urban Setting

Abstract

Dashboards are being increasingly used in the health field, and literature points out that accurate and efficient dashboards require not only dealing with data issues, but also ensuring that dashboards are user-friendly and that incorporate users' views and needs. The integration of evidence and data into decision aiding tools, such as dashboards, to assess and monitor environmental health (EH) in urban settings requires careful design. Departing from EH evidence and making use of the views of EH stakeholders and experts, this study aimed at defining requirements for a dashboard to help decision-makers analyzing and visualizing EH information in the Lisbon urban context. In order to set those requirements, it was combined a user-centered with a design card approach to engage EH potential end-users so as to collect their visualization preferences and gather information related to dashboard requirements. Specifically, three online group semi-structured interviews, involving 11 potential end-users from different organizations, were conducted; design cards with a set of visualization options regarding 17 indicators of built and natural environment determinants were used in the interviews to capture participants' preferences and their rationale; questions about other dashboard features were also asked; and the results from the interviews were synthesized into four separate, but interrelated features, and operationalized into 11 requirements for a dashboard to monitor EH in Lisbon. This study contributes to EH literature by producing knowledge to inform dashboard construction, by highlighting issues related with the usability, analysis, and visualization of data to inform EH decision-making in urban contexts, and by designing an approach that can be replicated to other EH dashboard contexts.

Developing policy-ready digital dashboards of geospatial access to emergency obstetric care: a survey of policymakers and researchers in sub-Saharan Africa

“…If available, such visual display would make recognising areas of poor EmOC geographical accessibility easier for policymakers and facilitate evidence-based policy response [17,26]. To guide the development of such fit-for-purpose dashboard, guarantee its uptake, and promote ownership, it is essential to gather user needs at the development stage from individuals who will use the dashboard [27][28][29] As such, our objective in this study was to survey policymakers and researchers on considerations needed for developing a policy-ready dashboard of geospatial access to EmOC in SSA.…”

Informing the Design of Data Visualization Tools to Monitor the COVID-19 Pandemic in Portugal: A Web-Delphi Participatory Approach

“…However, despite the highlighted importance of stakeholders’ opinions for dashboard design, the number of studies that integrate participatory methods to explore visualization options of dashboards is limited [ 8 ]. Most methods focus on determining the needs and requirements for dashboard design and functionalities rather than exploring the most preferred visualization format between suggested visual options [ 9 , 10 , 11 , 12 , 13 ].…”