Sex differences in brain metabolic activity: Beyond the concept of brain age

Abstract

We have read the article in PNAS by Goyal et al. (1) with great interest. The identification of underlying organic differences between female and male brains is of utmost importance to reach sex-sensitive precision medicine (2)(3)(4).The main findings of the paper (1), "the female brain has a persistently lower metabolic brain age-relative to their chronological age-compared with the male brain," lend themselves to the conclusion that women's brains are younger than men's. However, we would like to raise a number of considerations that might help revisit the main conclusion of the data presented.Goyal et al.(1) applied a supervised machine learning algorithm to multiregional, PET-based measurements of brain metabolism of a cohort of 205 participants. By training the algorithm on male data and applying it on female data, the authors noted that female brains appeared to be about 3.8 y younger than their chronological age. Similarly, when trained on female data, the model predicted male brains to be 2.4 y older than their actual age.Based on their previous findings, the authors concluded that this mismatch is due to the fact that the typical female brain is more youthful-that is, metabolically neotenous-than the male brain. Unfortunately, to the best of our knowledge, the actual differences between male and female neoteny and/or aerobic glycolysis (AG) processes have not yet been established. A few points might help identify alternative interpretations.First, it should be noted that the metabolic data used for training the model are multiparametric, and AG might not be the most important player in the sex difference observed. Underestimation of women's chronologic age based on a male-trained model might therefore simply indicate a different ratio of AG to oxidative glycolysis between men and women. Sex and gender differences in brain metabolism in general are still very poorly understood (5).Second, higher female AG might not be necessarily a sign of younger metabolic age. AG takes only a small portion of the entire brain metabolism of the adult brain (10%), and this percentage is subject to variations due to age, as well as to brain regions (6), brain activity (7) and neurodegeneration (8). If confirmed, higher female AG might represent increased brain activity and even vulnerability to degeneration in women.Finally, Goyal et al.(1) mention that their random forest algorithm could not accurately predict sex using said brain metabolic measures. This calls into question the extent of brain differences in this set of metabolic data.Despite their controversial interpretation, this set of results suggests that fundamental differences exist between male and female metabolic brain rates, which deserve further investigation. Goyal et al.(1) should be praised for clearly identifying the issue of sex stratification in artificial intelligence (AI)-based brain research. The authors' data, in our view, demonstrate that algorithms trained on one sex are not necessarily predictive for the other sex, calling for sex-specific tra...

Metabolic Sex Dimorphism of the Brain at the Gene, Cell, and Tissue Level

“…Brain glucose metabolism can be visualized with brain imaging techniques at the level of brain structure, neuronal activity, and functional circuitry (59). Leveraging multitracer position-emission tomography (PET) scans of >200 cognitively normal individuals, aerobic glycolysis, estimated by the difference between total glucose use and oxygen consumption, was found to be higher in female brain as compared with males of the same age (26,60,61). Oxygen consumption can be contributed by other metabolic inputs of the tricarboxylic acid cycle such as glutamate and lipid, and thus it is important to note that alternative or complementary interpretations of this result is possible such as sex bias in mitochondrial fuel selection.…”

Sex- and age-specific associations between cardiometabolic risk and white matter brain age in the UK Biobank cohort

“…We ran three age prediction models: 1) mixed-sex, 2) female only, and 3) male only, to obtain sex-specific BAG values [53,95] as well as general BAG estimates based on the mixed sample.…”

“…While DTI is commonly used to estimate WM indices that are highly sensitive to age [73,86,87,88], biophysical diffusion models such as WMTI [85], which is derived from DKI [84], may more accurately capture WM tissue structure complexity [84,89], thus providing greater biological specificity [90]. Given previous work indicating structural and functional sex differences in the human brain [91,92,93,94], the diffusion metrics were used as input features to three separate prediction models; 1) mixed-sex, 2) female only, and 3) male only, in order to improve the accuracy of the sex-specific analyses [53,95,96]. We used linear regression models to assess whether associations between BAG and BMI, WHR, BF%, and APOE genotype varied i) between males and females, ii) according to age at menopause in females, and iii) across different age groups in males and females.…”

Sex and gender differences in Alzheimer’s disease: current challenges and implications for clinical practice

“…Thus far, the longer life expectancy of women has been ascribed to biological factors as well as genderspecific lifestyle attitudes [29]. Biologically, for instance, recent studies report that women have younger brains in terms of metabolic activity than men [30,31]. Further, men of certain ages appear to be more vulnerable to death by cardiovascular events, as the Framingham's heart study showed higher midlife cardiovascular mortality in men than in women [19].…”