Shared and Unshared Barriers to Cancer Symptom Management Among Urban and Rural American Indians

Abstract

Purpose Before the end of the 20th century, American Indians (AIs) primarily resided in non-metropolitan areas. Shifting demographic trends have led to a majority of AIs now living in urban areas, leading to new health care barriers for AIs. AIs experience the poorest survival from all cancers combined compared to all other racial groups. Identifying and classifying barriers to cancer care may facilitate supportive interventions and programs to improve access and treatment. Methods A 5-year cancer symptom management project targeted AIs in the Southwest. The first phase of the randomized clinical trial consisted of 13 focus groups (N=126) of cancer patients/survivors and their caregivers. Discussions explored existing and perceived barriers and facilitators to cancer symptom management and cancer treatment. Findings Significant barriers to cancer-related care were found among urban AIs, as compared to their rural counterparts. Barriers were classified within 4 sub-groups: a) structural, b) physical, c) supportive, or d) cultural. Urban AIs reported barriers that are both structural and physical (inadequate access to care and public transportation) and supportive (lack of support, resources and technology, and less access to traditional healing). Rural participants reported communication and culture barriers (language differences, illness beliefs and low levels of cancer care knowledge), as well as unique structural, physical and supportive barriers. Conclusion It is important to identify and understand culturally and geographically influenced barriers to cancer treatment and symptom management. We provide recommendations for strategies to reduce health disparities for AIs that are appropriate to their region of residence and barrier type.

Culture-broker and medical decoder: contributions of caregivers in American Indian cancer trajectories

“…Te literature demonstrates that culture-bound beliefs can act as barriers to cancer care. 11 Caregivers report that many American Indians do not share their illness with others because they are private individuals who are uncomfortable and unable to "bring their burdens home." Many limit communication with medical providers because of discomfort and/or the preference for privacy.…”

Engaging Stakeholders in the Development of an eHealth Intervention for Cancer Symptom Management for Rural Residents

“…Qualitative description is a form of naturalistic inquiry that seeks to understand a phenomenon that might occur outside of research. This approach does not make a priori assumptions and seeks to describe what is occurring in the lived experiences of the participants . Three coders read each transcript and met weekly to discuss the codes and themes and come to a consensus.…”

Enrolling Minority and Underserved Populations in Cancer Clinical Research

“…Among numerous barriers noted in the literature, 4,11,12 two particular factors often cited are lack of transportation to and from the clinical research site and the travel distance to the research site. 13–15 Location of the clinical trial site becomes increasingly important to clinical trial success. Place of residence and race were found to be significant predictors of participation in therapeutic and non-therapeutic clinical trials, although patterns differed somewhat between the types of studies.…”