GaN films were grown on porous SiC and GaN templates using both plasma-assisted molecular beam epitaxy (PAMBE) and metal-organic chemical vapor deposition (MOCVD) to evaluate possible advantage of epitaxy on a porous substrate. For the growth of GaN on porous SiC by PAMBE, transmission electron microscopy (TEM) observations indicate that the exposed SiC suface pores tend to extend into the GaN film as open tubes and to trap Ga droplets. The GaN layers grown on porous templates have fewer threading dislocations originating at the interface, but they have additional defects in the form of half-loop dislocations which act to relieve the strain in the films. For PAMBE of GaN on porous GaN, dislocations existing in the porous seed layer are seen to propagate through the porous layer into the overgrown GaN, resulting in no dislocation reduction. For MOCVD of GaN on porous GaN, the initial regrowth tend to bend laterally the dislocations and enhance their annihilation, resulting in 5-10× fewer dislocations in the overgrown film.