Platinum (Pt)-based materials are inevitably among the best-performing electrocatalysts for hydrogen evolution reaction (HER). MoS was suggested to be a potent HER catalyst to replace Pt in this reaction by theoretical modeling; however, in practice, this dream remains elusive. Here we show a facile one-pot bottom-up synthesis of Pt-MoS composites using electrochemical reduction in an electrolytic bath of Pt precursor and ammonium tetrathiomolybdate under ambient conditions. By modifying the millimolar concentration of Pt precursors, composites of different surface elemental composition are fabricated; specifically, PtMoS, PtMoS, PtMoS, and PtMoS. All electrodeposited Pt-MoS hybrids showcase low overpotentials and small Tafel slopes that outperform MoS as an electrocatalyst. Tantamount to electrodeposited Pt, the rate-limiting process in the HER mechanism is determined to be the Heyrovsky desorption across Pt-MoS hybrids and starkly swings from the rate-determining Volmer adsorption step in MoS. The Pt-MoS composites are equipped with catalytic performance that closely mirrors that of electrodeposited Pt, in particular the HER kinetics for PtMoS and PtMoS. This work advocates electrosynthesis as a cost-effective method for catalyst design and fabrication of competent composite materials for water splitting applications.