Smartphone-Based Physical Activity Telecoaching in Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease: Mixed-Methods Study on Patient Experiences and Lessons for Implementation

Abstract

BackgroundTelecoaching approaches can enhance physical activity (PA) in patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD). However, their effectiveness is likely to be influenced by intervention-specific characteristics.ObjectiveThis study aimed to assess the acceptability, actual usage, and feasibility of a complex PA telecoaching intervention from both patient and coach perspectives and link these to the effectiveness of the intervention.MethodsWe conducted a mixed-methods study based on the completers of the intervention group (N=159) included in an (effective) 12-week PA telecoaching intervention. This semiautomated telecoaching intervention consisted of a step counter and a smartphone app. Data from a project-tailored questionnaire (quantitative data) were combined with data from patient interviews and a coach focus group (qualitative data) to investigate patient and coach acceptability, actual usage, and feasibility of the intervention. The degree of actual usage of the smartphone and step counter was also derived from app data. Both actual usage and perception of feasibility were linked to objectively measured change in PA.ResultsThe intervention was well accepted and perceived as feasible by all coaches present in the focus group as well by patients, with 89.3% (142/159) of patients indicating that they enjoyed taking part. Only a minority of patients (8.2%; 13/159) reported that they found it difficult to use the smartphone. Actual usage of the step counter was excellent, with patients wearing it for a median (25th-75th percentiles) of 6.3 (5.8-6.8) days per week, which did not change over time (P=.98). The smartphone interface was used less frequently and actual usage of all daily tasks decreased significantly over time (P<.001). Patients needing more contact time had a smaller increase in PA, with mean (SD) of +193 (SD 2375) steps per day, +907 (SD 2306) steps per day, and +1489 (SD 2310) steps per day in high, medium, and low contact time groups, respectively; P for-trend=.01. The overall actual usage of the different components of the intervention was not associated with change in step count in the total group (P=.63).ConclusionsThe 12-week semiautomated PA telecoaching intervention was well accepted and feasible for patients with COPD and their coaches. The actual usage of the step counter was excellent, whereas actual usage of the smartphone tasks was lower and decreased over time. Patients who required more contact experienced less PA benefits.Trial RegistrationClinicalTrials.gov NCT02158065; http://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/NCT02158065 (Archived by WebCite at http://www.webcitation.org/73bsaudy9)

A qualitative exploration of cardiovascular disease patients’ views and experiences with an eHealth cardiac rehabilitation intervention: The PATHway Project

“…This lack of awareness may seem surprising given that each participant was exposed to a standardised four-week familiarisation period. Previous qualitative research has found that participants felt they needed more than a familiarization period before they would feel confident about using the technology [19], especially when a system encompasses a wide range of services as was the case with PATHway. It would seem there is a need for dedicated research into the appropriate strategies needed in eHealth interventions to optimise participants' familiarity with all components of the system.…”

Accuracy of consumer-based activity trackers as measuring tool and coaching device in patients with COPD and healthy controls

“…distinguishing more from less active days in an individual subject) in a practical way and that they can be used in physical activity coaching interventions. The use of hip worn physical activity trackers has shown to be effective to improve physical activity in previous coaching trials [16,29]. Subjects in coaching interventions should be instructed to wear the device during waking hours.…”

“…By monitoring and providing (real-time) feedback to patients, these step counters or activity trackers play a crucial role in the coaching interventions [15]. A qualitative analysis showed that 76.1% of the patients involved in a tele coaching intervention considered the step counter as the most important part of the intervention [16]. The prerequisite for using these activity trackers to coach individual patients is that they can accurately capture the individual day-by-day changes.…”

ERS International Congress, Madrid, 2019: highlights from the Respiratory Infections Assembly

“…Leg muscle pain during walks was more frequently reported in Urban Training than usual care, without differences in any of the other adverse events. Dr Gimeno-Santos concluded her talk by briefly presenting other recently published studies on the duration, implementation and determinants of physical activity in COPD [81][82][83][84].…”