Social-ecological Resilience and Biodiversity Conservation in a 900-year-old Protected Area

Abstract

ABSTRACT. Protected areas are increasingly being recognized as coupled social-ecological systems, whose effectiveness depends on their resilience. Here I present a historical profile of an individual case study, the New Forest (England), which was first designated as a protected area more than 900 years ago. Uniquely, a traditional pattern of land use has been maintained ever since, providing a rare opportunity to examine the resilience of an integrated social-ecological system over nine centuries. The New Forest demonstrates that over the long term, coupled social-ecological systems can be resilient to major internal and external shocks, including climate change, mass human mortality and war. Changes in governance had the greatest impact on the reserve itself, with two major crises identified in the mid-19th and 20th centuries. Resolution of these crises depended on the formation of alliances between local people and external partners, including the general public, a process that was supported by improvements in visitor access. Over a timescale of centuries, this social-ecological system has been highly dynamic in disturbance regimes but relatively stable in land use patterns. However, the factors underpinning resilience have changed over time. This case study suggests that for protected areas to be effective over the long term, social structures and institutions as well as environmental processes require adaptive capacity.

The Identification of Potential Resilient Estuary-based Enterprises to Encourage Economic Empowerment in South Africa: a Toolkit Approach

“…First, resilience has been applied widely to SESs and is increasingly being used to help understand, manage, and govern complex SESs (Walker et al 2002, Ostrom 2007. For example, it has been applied to political ecology and resource management (Berkes et al 1998, Berkes 1999, as well as to a variety of specific ecosystems that include: rangelands (Anderies 2002); lakes and wetlands (Gunderson 2001, Olsson et al 2004); coral reefs (Hughes et al 2005); a protected area (Newton 2011); and an evolving urban system (Bures and Kanapaux 2011). Step 1 -ecosystem services supply and demand assessment;…”

Elevated elephant density does not improve ecotourism opportunities: convergence in social and ecological objectives

“…For a protected area to be effective, it is important that managers address the factors responsible for biodiversity loss (Newton 2011). It is thus strongly recommended that elephant densities in the AENP be reduced and that the population be maintained at the stocking rates and distribution patterns recommended to maintain biodiversity.…”

“…Protected areas are subjected to both natural and human-induced disturbances (e.g., drought, poaching, water abstraction, and political change), and effective management approaches are required to enable conservation objectives to be achieved while ensuring that human needs are met (Newton 2011). Protected areas can thus be viewed as linked social-ecological systems, consisting of a suite of actors (managers, tourists, animals, plants) that cooccur in and around the protected areas.…”

“…Protected areas can thus be viewed as linked social-ecological systems, consisting of a suite of actors (managers, tourists, animals, plants) that cooccur in and around the protected areas. For protected areas to persist, they therefore need to be resilient in both the social and ecological domains (Newton 2011). Resilience can be defined as the capacity of a system to absorb disturbance and reorganize while undergoing change so as to retain the same function, structure, and feedbacks (Walker et al 2004).…”

Restoration of forest resilience: An achievable goal?

“…In the context of socialecological systems, Carpenter et al (2005) suggested that ecological resilience cannot be measured directly, but must be estimated by means of resilience surrogates, namely indirect proxies that are derived from theory. Methods of identifying such surrogates include stakeholder assessments, model explorations, historical profiling and case study comparison (Carpenter et al 2005), which can potentially be applied to forested systems (Newton 2011). Brand and Jax (2007) consider situations where it is possible to identify the key controlling variables.…”