In this essay I argue that theory in psychology need not be mystifying to non-theorists. I use feminist postmodern theory and the discourses of masculinity to demonstrate how theory can facilitate the exploration of questions and reveal what has been marginalized and obscured. My premise is further illustrated by an examination of the male sex drive discourse. I suggest in conclusion that the question in any theory is always about the choice of question.
CAN WE DEMYSTIFY THEORY? EXAMINING MASCULINITY DISCOURSES AND FEMINIST POSTMODERN THEORYTheories come and go. After all, how many psychologists are still using Hull's postulates? As John Dewey (1910) observed, intellectual progress occurs through the sheer abandonment of questions. We do not solve them. We get over them.Why does theory loom as such an obstacle for many psychologists? Why do theorists seem like a small and exclusive club? Perhaps we have mystified theory. But psychology as it has evolved as a discipline has also increasingly given a negative value to the complex work of theory development and drained it of importance.I would suggest that if we want theory to be important in the future of psychology, we have to show that theory is valuable for its own sake as a route to understanding, rather than as a privileged form of special authority (Rosenau, 1992). And we have to give up our arcane terms to signal that others are welcome to the club. Too often theorists get into intense debates only with each other, and toss around the names of philosophers not always known to other psychologists, like Binswanger or Foucault. It was Binswanger who said, in his existential way, that "life is one thing after another." A simple and profound idea that says it all for an existentialist. As for Foucault, without getting into the This document is copyrighted by the American Psychological Association or one of its allied publishers.This article is intended solely for the personal use of the individual user and is not to be disseminated broadly.1 I would also like to acknowledge the influence of the following theorists on my ideas: