Solidarity and disparity: Declining labor union density and changing racial and educational mortality inequities in the United States

Abstract

Background: Recently, United States life expectancy has stagnated or declined for the poor and working class and risen for the middle and upper classes. Declining labor-union density-the percent of workers who are unionized-has precipitated burgeoning income inequity. We examined whether it has also exacerbated racial and educational mortality inequities.Methods: From CDC, we obtained state-level all-cause and overdose/suicide mortality overall and by gender, gender-race, and gender-education from 1986-2016. State-level union density and demographic and economic confounders came from the Current Population Survey. State-level policy confounders included the minimum wage, the generosity of Aid to Families with Dependent Children or Temporary Assistance for Needy Families, and the generosity of unemployment insurance. To model the exposure-outcome relationship, we used marginal structural modeling. Using state-level inverse-probability-of-treatment-weighted Poisson models with state and year fixed effects, we estimated 3-year moving average union density's effects on the following year's mortality rates. Then, we tested for gender, gender-race, and gender-education effect-modification. Finally, we estimated how racial and educational all-cause mortality inequities would change if union density increased to 1985 or 1988 levels, respectively.Results: Overall, a 10% increase in union density was associated with a 17% relative decrease in overdose/suicide mortality (95% confidence interval [CI]: 0.70, 0.98), or 5.7 lives saved per 100 000 person-years (95% CI: −10.7, −0.7). Union density's absolute (lives-saved) effects on overdose/suicide mortality were stronger for men than women, but its relative effects were similar across genders. Union density had little effect on all-cause mortality overall or across subgroups, and modeling suggested union-density increases would not affect mortality inequities.Conclusions: Declining union density (as operationalized in this study) may not explain all-cause mortality inequities, although increases in union density may reduce overdose/suicide mortality. K E Y W O R D S fatal overdose epidemic, health disparities, health inequities, labor movement, labor unions, marginal structural models, mortality inequities, social determinants of health

Economic influences on population health in the United States: Toward policymaking driven by data and evidence

“…Other studies have demonstrated worsening mental health and increases in overall and drug overdose mortality after manufacturing plant closures [ 71 – 73 ]. Falling participation in labor unions has been linked to rising mortality rates from suicide and drug overdose [ 74 ]. Structural racism—as manifest by racial gaps in economic opportunity, racial gaps in wealth, racial segregation, and risk of incarceration—have also been negatively associated with a range of health outcomes, particularly for Black Americans [ 60 , 75 – 77 ].…”

Suicide, overdose and worker exit in a cohort of Michigan autoworkers

“…30 Another study found that higher state-wide union density was associated with lower mortality rates for suicide and overdose. 31 In a study directly relevant to this one, a difference-in-differences approach estimated an association between county-level automobile assembly closures, from 1999 to 2016, and opioid mortality. 32…”

Trends in the diagnosis of diseases of despair in the United States, 2009–2018: a retrospective cohort study

“…33 Others have, for instance, linked rising rates of death of despair with stagnant minimum wage. [34][35][36] However, others argue that the phenomenon is more attributable to other contextual factors such as a worsening drug environment [37][38][39] ; the collapse of social institutions and weakening of traditional social bonds (eg, reduced church attendance, 40 41 union membership, 42 etc) 43 ; hospital closures and shortages (particularly in rural areas) 44 ; a generalised cultural rise in loneliness, depression, alienation and anxiety 45 ; higher relative gun ownership in rural areas 46 ; racial resentment and a growing sense of social status loss 47 among poor whites; and moral decadence (ie, a 'loss of virtue' in ethnically white rural communities). 48 49 Using big data to build predictive models of neighbourhoods or census tracts where people may be at greatest risk would help clarify current debates about past causation and identify zones of resilience, and also offer a future tool of clinical and public health import.…”