Laser photofragmentation spectroscopy of the I-•adenine (I-•A) and H2PO3-•adenine (H2PO3-•A) clusters has been utilized for the first time across the electron detachment thresholds to explore how the anion identity affects intra-cluster electron transfer. Ionic photofragmentation is weak for both clusters, despite strong photodepletion, revealing that both clusters decay predominantly by electron detachment. The spectra of I-•A display a prominent dipole-bound excited state in the region of the vertical detachment energy, which relaxes to produce deprotonated adenine. In contrast, photoexcitation of H2PO3-•A in the near-threshold region does not access a dipole-bound state, but instead displays photofragmentation properties associated with ultrafast decay of an adenine-localized -* transition. Notably, the experimental electron detachment onset of H2PO3-•A is around 4.7 eV. This value is substantially reduced compared to the VDE expected for detachment of a simple anion-dipole complex. The lower VDE of H2PO3-•A can be traced to initial ionization of the adenine, which is followed by significant rearrangement of a hydrogen atom on the neutral surface. We conclude that these dynamics quench access to a dipole-bound excited state for H2PO3-•A. Despite the fact that the excess negative charge is located on H2PO3in the ground-state cluster, the anion in this cluster does not act as a free electron source to initiate free electron attachment or dissociation in the nucleobase. However, the H2PO3-•A cluster represents an important new example of an anionic cluster where ionization occurs from the initial neutral moiety of the cluster, and where photodetachment initiates intra-molecular hydrogen atom transfer.