i
AbstractLack of baseline quantitative data on the reproductive and productive performance of goats in Bali Province has limited our ability to identify factors that could lead to their improvement. This study aimed to rectify this lack of data and to measure constraints to, challenges of, and opportunities for improving goat production in Bali, through a hybrid method of Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities and Threats and Analytic Hierarchy Process analyses.Data was collected through direct observations, structured formal household interviews, key informant interviews, focus group discussions, and case studies as well as from the surrounding environment and market assessments from January to September 2014. This involved interviewing 175 households with 2,017 goats. Of these, 63 households with 1,169 goats were in Rendang District, Karangasem Regency; 44 households with 590 goats were in Banjar, Busungbiu and Grogak Districts in Buleleng Regency; and 68 households with 258 goats were in Mendoyo District, Jembrana Regency. Data was analysed by using descriptive statistics, correlate bivariate and general linear model multivariate using SPSS version 24.Results revealed that households had an average of 2.3 labourers with a ratio of 5.2 ± 0.4 goats per labourer who were aged 42 ± 1 year. This indicated that household labourers in Bali Province worked 412 ± 9.9 hours/household/year to look after 11.5 ± 0.9 goats/flock in either battery or colony housing with a cut and carry feeding system. Farmers cultivated on average 1.4 ± 0.05 ha/household with vegetables or commodity plantations integrated with goat rearing for 10.5 ± 0.7 years. Of the 175 farmers, 63%, 21% and 15% of farmers graduated from Grades 6, 9 and 12, respectively, and only one farmer graduated from university. This study generated new, important and detailed information on goat production by smallholder farmers in Bali Province. Suggested ways to improve goat production included: High performance (as indicated by GM/doe) was associated with a higher turn off rate (underpinned by a higher reproductive rate); Organic goat rearing management in Rendang District was a model for Bali; The ideal labourer to goat flock size ratio was 1:20 goats; At least 25% of the flock should be does, with a 75% annual turn off rate; The kidding interval should be 8 months; Does should only be kept up to their fourth or fifth kidding; Farmers need to keep records of their goats; A -One gate marketing system‖ should be used to maintain profitable market prices; and Farmers needed networks with the Indonesia Research Institute for Animal Production to ensure quality breeds, feeds and efficient rearing goat management systems were used in Bali.