South America's biophysical involvement in international trade: the physical trade balances of Argentina, Bolivia, and Brazil in the light of ecologically unequal exchange

Abstract

International trade is becoming increasingly important in the strategies of industrialized economies ('core' countries) to meet their physical needs and maintain their social metabolism. Less industrialized ('non-core') countries, in particular those with low population densities such as countries in South America, provide a large share of the natural resources currently being used by the 'core' countries. This article analyzes the relations of biophysical exchange of Argentina, Bolivia, and Brazil with global 'core' and 'non-core' countries in order to add to a discussion of possible relations of different national economic policies, such as import substituting industrialization or neoliberal adjustment, on the countries' physical trade balances (PTBs). By that we will provide a biophysical reading of ecologically unequal exchange; by investigating whether there is a physical net trade flow from 'non-core' to 'core' countries, whether primary products dominate exports of 'non-core' countries in exchange for processed products from 'core' countries, and whether the notion of unfavorable mass-to-price relation for the trading 'non-core' countries applies (Hornborg 2012;Martinez-Alier 2007). The magnitudes, type of material, stage of processing and monetary value of the traded goods are analyzed for the time period from 1962 to 2011. The evaluations have been carried out for trade relations with the 'core' and the 'non-core' countries separately. Additionally, in order to trace the so-called China Effect, which led to the period of new extractivism, the quantities exported to China are shown separately. The results indicate that the three countries examined are net exporters of physical quantities. The physical involvement in 'core'-and 'non-core'-related international trade differs greatly, but at the same time the relative importance of the 'core' as trading partner has decreased steadily over the five decades. Still, 'core'-related trade involves the most unfavorable mass-to-price relation. These conditions, i.e. high importance of unprocessed export commodities, low average unit prices, and an unfavorable monetary trade balance (MTB), reveal many characteristics of an ecologically unequal exchange. This is especially true for Argentina and Brazil. Due to its lower economic performance and limited involvement in international trade, Bolivia to some extent represents an exception. Keywords: Ecologically unequal exchange, physical trade balance, South America, Argentina, Bolivia, Brazil. RésuméLe commerce international devient de plus en plus important pour les économies industrialisées afin de satisfaire leurs besoins matériels et maintenir leur fonctionnement social. Les pays en voie de développement, en particulier ceux qui présentent une faible densité de population comme l'Amérique du Sud, fournissent une 1 Christian Dorninger, PhD candidate, Faculty of Sustainability, Leuphana University of Lüneburg, Germany. E-mail: christian.dorninger "at" leuphana.de. This article is based on his Masters thesis i...

Global patterns of ecologically unequal exchange: Implications for sustainability in the 21st century

“…To date, empirical evidence to support the theoretical notion of ecologically unequal exchange as a structural feature of the global economy is still very scarce. While there is a range of conceptual work (Hornborg, 2019(Hornborg, , 1998 and of case studies that provide empirical evidence for the presence of ecologically unequal exchange between or within single nation states (Dorninger and Eisenmenger, 2016; Infante-Amate and Yu et al, 2014;Zhang et al, 2018), for specific commodities or indicators (Jorgenson, 2012;Jorgenson and Clark, 2009b), or in historical perspectives (Bogadóttir, 2016;Hornborg, 2006), comprehensive global assessments of ecologically unequal exchange over decadal time periods have not previously been undertaken. The results of the only global assessment -where ecologically unequal exchange was assessed in terms of proportionality of physical and monetary trade, ecological intensity, and net-transfers (Moran et al, 2013) -have been called into question (Dorninger and Hornborg, 2015).…”

Changing social metabolism and environmental conflicts in India and South America

“…There is no room here to present all the evidence regarding South America's external trade (cf. Dorninger and Eisenmenger, 2016), but the relevance of an 'ecological Prebisch thesis', building on Prebisch's work at CEPAL (the United National Economic Commission for Latin America) conducted in the 1950s and 1960s, is stronger than ever (Pérez-Rincon, 2006). However, for India as a whole this argument on international terms of trade is not relevant, although it would be relevant for the accounts of Jharkhand, Odisha, and Chhattisgarh, i.e.…”

Las venas abiertas de América Latina en la era del Antropoceno: Un estudio biofísico del comercio exterior (1900-2016)

“…En la actualidad, se han publicado estimaciones MFA para la mayoría de las economías nacionales, incluyendo las latinoamericanas, entre 1970 y la actualidad. De hecho, existen numerosos análisis monográficos sobre América Latina a nivel regional (West & Schandl, 2013) por grupos de países (Russi et al, 2008;Dorninger & Eisenmenger, 2016;Samaniego, Vallejo & Martíez-Alier, 2017;Crespo-Marín & Pérez Rincón, 2019) o para estudios nacionales específicos como Colombia (Pérez Rincón, 2006;Vallejo, Pérez Rincón & Martinez-Alier, 2011), Chile (Giljum, 2004), Ecuador (Vallejo, 2010), Argentina (Manrique et al, 2013) y México (González Martínez & Schandl, 2008). 4 Los resultados derivados de estas recientes investigaciones han sido decisivos para arrojar luz sobre debate de las 'venas abiertas' y para caracterizar el papel de América Latina en el ascenso del Antropoceno.…”