Let Gn be the binomial random graph G(n, p = c/n) in the sparse regime, which as is well-known undergoes a phase transition at c = 1. Lynch (Random Structures Algorithms, 1992) showed that for every first order sentence φ, the limiting probability that Gn satisfies φ as n → ∞ exists, and moreover it is an analytic function of c. In this paper we consider the closure Lc in [0, 1] of the set Lc of all limiting probabilities of first order sentences in Gn. We show that there exists a critical value c0 ≈ 0.93 such that Lc = [0, 1] when c ≥ c0, whereas Lc misses at least one subinterval when c < c0. We extend these results to random d-uniform sparse hypergraphs, where the probability of a hyperedge is given by p = c/n d−1 .