Fiber Bragg grating (FBG) technology has shown a mutation in developing fiber optic-based sensors because of their tiny size, high dielectric strength, distributed sensing, and immunity to high voltage and magnetic field interference. Therefore, FBG sensors significantly improve performance and accuracy in the world of measurements. The reflectivity and bandwidth are the main parameters that can dramatically affect the sensing performance and accuracy. Each industrial application has its requirements regarding the reflectivity and bandwidth of the reflected wavelength. Optimizing such problems with multi-objective functions that might t with each other based on applications’ needs is a big challenge. Therefore, this paper presents an optimization method based on the nondominated sorting genetic algorithm II (NSGA-II), aiming at determining the optimum grating parameters to suit applications’ needs. To sum up, the optimization process aims to convert industrial applications’ requirements, including bandwidth and reflectivity, into the manufacturing setting of FBG sensors, including grating length and modulation refractive index. The method has been implemented using MATLAB and validated with other research work in the literature. Results proved the capability of the new way to determine the optimum grating parameters for fulfilling application requirements.