Speech-Language Pathologists' Perceptions of Their Preparation and Confidence for Providing Dysphagia Services

Abstract

Purpose The purpose of this study was to investigate the perceptions of speech-language pathologists (SLPs) regarding their academic preparation and current confidence levels for providing dysphagia services, and the relationship between their perceptions of graduate school preparation and their current levels of confidence. Method This study utilized an online survey to gather information from 374 American Speech-Language-Hearing Association–certified SLPs who currently provide dysphagia services in the United States. Surveys were primarily distributed through American Speech-Language-Hearing Association Special Interest Group forums and Facebook groups. The anonymous survey gathered information regarding SLPs' perceptions of academic preparation and current confidence levels for providing dysphagia services in 11 knowledge and skill areas. Results Findings indicated that more than half of respondents did not feel prepared following their graduate academic training in five of the 11 knowledge and skill areas related to dysphagia service delivery. However, about half of respondents indicated they were currently confident about their ability to provide services in eight of the 11 knowledge and skill areas. Findings also indicated that their current confidence levels to provide dysphagia services were significantly higher than their perceptions of preparation immediately following graduate school. However, no significant relationships were found between respondents' self-reported current confidence levels and their perceptions of the adequacy of their academic preparation. Conclusions Despite SLPs' low perceptions of the adequacy of their graduate preparation for providing dysphagia services in specific knowledge and skill areas immediately following graduation, they reported high confidence levels with respect to their actual service delivery. Implications of these findings are discussed.

Contextualising clinical reasoning within the clinical swallow evaluation: A scoping review and expert consultation

“…They reported that this inappropriateness of training was exacerbated by insufficiency in opportunities to develop these clinical skills in real-life scenarios. These sentiments are echoed in recent literature which describes the doubt and under-preparedness voiced by many novice SLTs in response to their training (Caesar & Kitila, 2020 ; Coutts, 2019 ; Singh et al, 2015 ).…”

Clinical practice patterns of speech‐language pathologists for screening and identifying dysphagia

“…In the context of clinicians' perceptions, Caesar and Kitila (2020) found that clinicians felt their academic graduate training left them inadequately prepared to treat dysphagia yet perceived themselves as delivering high-quality care. Though we found no connections with approaches or evidence base and age or years practicing, our findings likely display an application of clinical decision-making that draws on a combination of contextual factors throughout a clinician's career.…”

Knowledge and Perceptions of Speech-Language Pathology Students Participating in a Feeding Training Program: A Pilot Study

“…22 McCoy and Desai 24 surveyed 715 SLPs regarding their perceptions on feeling prepared to provide dysphagia services following graduate school. Findings revealed that 61% did not feel adequately prepared and only 5.5% felt “very competent.” Caesar and Kitila 25 surveyed 374 SLPs on their perceptions of preparedness and confidence for providing dysphagia services. Approximately 60% of respondents completed only one or no dysphagia-related externship during graduate school.…”