Cold seep communities around gas hydrate mounds (pingos) in the Western Barents Sea (76°N, 16°E, ~400 m depth) were investigated with high resolution, geographically referenced images acquired with an ROV and towed camera. Four pingos associated with seabed methane release hosted diverse biological communities of mainly non-seep (background) species including commercially important fish and crustaceans, as well as a species new to this area (the snow crab Chionoecetes 15 opilio). We attribute the presence of most benthic community members to habitat heterogeneity and the occurrence of hard substrates (methane derived authigenic carbonates), particularly the most abundant phyla (Cnidaria and Porifera), though food availability and exposure to a diverse microbial community is also important for certain taxa. Only one chemosynthesis based species was confirmed, the siboglinid frenulate polychaete, Oligobrachia haakonmosbiensis. Overall, the pingo communities formed two distinct clusters, distinguished by the presence or absence of frenulates. Methane gas advection through sediments 20 was absent below the single pingo that lacked frenulates, while seismic profiles indicated gas saturated sediment below the other frenulate colonized pingos. The absence of frenulates could not be explained by sediment sulfide concentrations, despite these worms likely containing sulfide oxidizing symbionts. We propose that high levels of seafloor methane seepage linked to sub-surface gas reservoirs support an abundant and active sediment methanotrophic community that maintains high sulfide fluxes and serves as a carbon source for frenulate worms. The pingo currently lacking a sub-surface gas source and lower 25 methane concentrations has lower sulfide flux rates and limited amounts of carbon insufficient to support frenulates. Two previously undocumented behaviors were visible through the images: grazing activity of snow crabs on bacterial mats, and seafloor crawling of Nothria conchylega onuphid polychaetes.Biogeosciences Discuss., https://doi