State of Multicultural Neuropsychological Assessment in Children: Current Research Issues

Abstract

Scientific attention to cultural considerations in child neuropsychological assessment has not developed parallel to the focus these issues have received in adult and elderly neuropsychological assessment. There are limited data on the presence, magnitude, etiology, and implications of culture-related differences in cognitive test performance among children. This preliminary report reviews the available empirical literature on the current state of multicultural neuropsychological assessment in children. The review identified articles by searching PubMed and PsycINFO databases, and the tables of contents of Developmental Neuropsychology and Child Neuropsychology from 2003-2008. Of the 1,834 abstracts reviewed, ten papers met inclusion criteria for the review. Five studies were completed in America; four of these compared performance between ethnic groups while the fifth examined neighborhood level poverty indicators exclusively within African-American children. Of the five international studies, all established local normative data and/or were exploratory investigations of neuropsychological functions in specific cultural groups, including Taiwanese infants, South African youth, and bilingual British children. Taken together, the results yield important clinical and research data that begin to inform many of the complex and fascinating mechanisms by which ethnic identity and culture impact cognitive development and the neuropsychological assessment of children. A critique of the existing literature and directions for future research are provided.

Neurocognitive dysfunction in hematopoietic cell transplant recipients: expert review from the late effects and Quality of Life Working Committee of the CIBMTR and complications and Quality of Life Working Party of the EBMT

“…Finally, cultural differences and contextual understanding of neurocognitive function may impact neurocognitive testing, bias results, and lessen the validity of findings. 23 …”

Cross-Cultural Neuropsychology: History and Prospects

“…Furthermore, a significant amount of research in cross-cultural neuropsychology is found from the 21 st century (e.g., Arias et al, 2019;Brickman, Cabo, & Manly, 2006;Byrd et al, 2008;Chiao et al, 2017;Duggan, 2019;Duggan et al, 2019;Fernández, & Abe, 2018;Garratt & Kelly, 2007;Golden & Thomas, 2000;Jacobs et al, 1997;Manly, 2008;Melikyan, Puente, & Agranovich, 2020;Nielsen et al, 2018;Nikolaou & Constantinidou, 2019;Pedraza, & Mungas, 2008;Puente et al, 2000;Rosselli, & Ardila, 2003). Several neuropsychology journals express their interest in publishing papers dealing with cultural issues in neuropsychology, including the Journal of Clinical and Experimental Neuropsychology, Archives of Clinical Neuropsychology, and Applied Neuropsychology.…”

Features Of Executive Functions Development In Moscow And Kazan Preschoolers

“…That is why cross-cultural studies present great interest to developmental psychology as they make it possible to evaluate and compare how various environmental factors resulting from specific features of cultures under investigation, on the one hand, and individual differences, on the other, influence the formation of executive functions. Given the obvious significance and usefulness of such studies many scientists have to note that there has been insufficient empirical research in investigating cultural differences in children's performance of cognitive regulation tasks (Byrd et al, 2008;Han et al, 2013). As a result, the present study was devoted to the examination of the developmental features of executive functions in preschool children belonging to two most wide-spread cultures -Russian and Tatarpresent on the territory of the Russian Federation, and, in particular, in its largest centres (Moscow and Kazan).…”