X-ray resonant magnetic reflectivity (XRMR) allows for the simultaneous measurement of structural, optical, and magneto-optic properties and depth profiles of a variety of thin film samples. However, a same-beamtime same-sample systematic quantitative comparison of the magnetic properties observed using XRMR and x-ray magnetic circular dichroism (XMCD) is still pending. Here, the XRMR results (Pt L 3 absorption edge) for the magnetic proximity effect in Pt deposited on the two different ferromagnetic materials Fe and Co 33 Fe 67 are compared with quantitatively analyzed XMCD results. The obtained results are in very good quantitative agreement between the absorptionbased (XMCD) and reflectivity-based (XRMR) techniques, taking into account an ab initio calculated magneto-optic conversion factor for the XRMR analysis. Thus, it is shown that XRMR provides quantitative reliable spin depth profiles important for spintronic and spin caloritronic transport phenomena at this type of magnetic interfaces.