The role of each of the Streptococcus mutans gif genes coding for glucan synthesis in cariogenesis was evaluated by using strain UA130 in the specific-pathogen-free (SPF) rat model system. Mutants defective in either or both of the genes required for insoluble glucan synthesis, the g#B7 and goT genes, exhibited markedly reduced levels of smooth-surface carious lesions relative to that of the parental organism. Likewise, the mutant defective in the gtJD gene coding for the glucosyltransferase-S enzyme synthesizing water-soluble glucans also produced significantly fewer smooth-surface lesions than strain UA130. None of these mutations markedly altered the rate of sulcal caries induction relative to that of the parental organism. In addition, a mutant of strain UA130 defective in the gtfA gene was reexamined in the SPF rat model. In contrast to previous results from a gnotobiotic rat system, these mutants also induced significantly fewer smooth-surface carious lesions compared with that by strain UA130. These results suggest that all four genes are important for smooth-surface caries formation. Furthermore, these results are discussed relative to the differences in the diets utilized in the SPF and gnotobiotic rat model systems for assessing the virulence factors of S. mutans. Strain Relevant property Source S. mutans UA130S UA130 maintained in San Antonio, Tex. P. Caufielda UA13OS(pTH10) UA130S containing pTH10 (Em') This study UA13OR UA130 maintained in Rochester, N.Y. P. Caufielda GS5B GS5 with inactive gtfB (Emr) 1 GS5DD GS5 with inactive gtfD (Tetr) 9 UA130B UA130S with inactive gtfB (Emr) This study UA130C UA130S with inactive gtfC (Em') This study UA130BC UA130S with inactive gtfB and gtfC (Emr) This study UA13ODD UA130S with inactive gtfD (Tetr) This study UAB747 UA130 with inactive gtfA (Em') 2 UA13ORR UA13OR isolated from SPF rats This study UA130SR UA130(pTH10) isolated from SPF rats (Ems) This study S. sobrinus 6715 Highly cariogenic in rats 4