Stress analysis of a carbon fiber-reinforced epoxy plate with a hole undergoing tension: A comparison of finite element analysis, strain gages, and infrared thermography

Abstract

This is the first study, to the authors' knowledge, to simultaneously perform a direct comparison of finite element analysis, strain gage measurements, and infrared thermography for stress analysis under both static and dynamics tensile loads of the classic geometry of a composite plate with a center hole. The plate was made from a carbon fiber-reinforced epoxy composite with dimensions of 250 mm length × 25 mm width × 2.2 mm thickness and a 5 mm diameter center hole. Using static tensile loads of 1000 N, 2000 N, and 3000 N, the plate Von Mises stress field was evaluated using strain gages versus finite element analysis. Using cyclic tensile loads of 1000 N and 1600 N at 5 Hz, the plate Von Mises stress field was assessed using strain gages versus infrared thermography. The strain gages versus finite element analysis line-of-best-fit showed poor agreement (slope = 2.1, R = 0.81), although the slope could easily be applied as a correction factor when comparing the two methods. The strain gages versus infrared thermography showed much better agreement (slope = 0.95, R = 0.91). Finite element analysis displayed a “butterfly” stress field around the hole with peaks of 73.5 MPa (at 1000 N), 147 MPa (at 2000 N), and 220.5 MPa (at 3000 N). Infrared thermography showed a “ring” of high stress around the hole with peaks of 74.8 MPa (at 1000 N) and 102.9 MPa (at 1600 N). All three methods showed similar relative trends for the carbon fiber-reinforced epoxy plate.

Empirical modeling of force and temperature in drilling bone-simulating hybrid composites

“…Other studies were performed on artificial cancellous foam blocks. 10,13,17 These studies confirmed similarities between the behaviors of human bones and bone-mimicking materials, including under drilling conditions, which enables their widespread use in important applications such as surgical training or preoperative planning in robotic surgery. However, the research on complete bone-mimicking structures (i.e.…”

“…Similarly, drill breakthrough can occur as a result of uncontrolled forces, causing significant harm to the surrounding tissue. 13 Also, large forces could promote crack formation, which could lead to prosthetic or bone fracture. 14 In addition, the forces (i.e., drilling and thrust forces) are the main cause of the heat generation through the drilling process.…”

Glass fiber/polypropylene composites with potential of bone fracture fixation plates: Manufacturing process and mechanical characterization

“…5 Also, thermoset polymers are not polymerized completely, which means some monomers still exist in the material after the polymerization. 5 Examples of thermosets, which utilized as biomaterials, are epoxy polymer and polymethylmethacrylate (PMMA) 5,19,38–44,48–50 On the other hand, the usage of thermoplastic polymers due to the ability of reshaping to the bone shape during the surgery by simply applying heat, is increasing. 5 Additional advantage of thermoplastic polymers is the greater fracture toughness compared to thermosets.…”

Damage tracking of notched composite plates by thermography—Experimental observations and analytical model for damage onset

“…Ref. 11 compared the utilization of three distinct techniques to assess the stress around the hole of a notched CFRP composite, under both static and dynamics tensile loads. It was used SG measurements, FE analysis and IRT, with good agreements.…”