Structural and Functional Alterations in Right Dorsomedial Prefrontal and Left Insular Cortex Co-Localize in Adolescents with Aggressive Behaviour: An ALE Meta-Analysis

Abstract

Recent neuroimaging work has suggested that aggressive behaviour (AB) is associated with structural and functional brain abnormalities in processes subserving emotion processing and regulation. However, most neuroimaging studies on AB to date only contain relatively small sample sizes. To objectively investigate the consistency of previous structural and functional research in adolescent AB, we performed a systematic literature review and two coordinate-based activation likelihood estimation meta-analyses on eight VBM and nine functional neuroimaging studies in a total of 783 participants (408 [224AB/184 controls] and 375 [215 AB/160 controls] for structural and functional analysis respectively). We found 19 structural and eight functional foci of significant alterations in adolescents with AB, mainly located within the emotion processing and regulation network (including orbitofrontal, dorsomedial prefrontal and limbic cortex). A subsequent conjunction analysis revealed that functional and structural alterations co-localize in right dorsomedial prefrontal cortex and left insula. Our results are in line with meta-analytic work as well as structural, functional and connectivity findings to date, all of which make a strong point for the involvement of a network of brain areas responsible for emotion processing and regulation, which is disrupted in AB. Increased knowledge about the behavioural and neuronal underpinnings of AB is crucial for the development of novel and implementation of existing treatment strategies. Longitudinal research studies will have to show whether the observed alterations are a result or primary cause of the phenotypic characteristics in AB.

Children’s brain activation during risky decision-making: A contributor to substance problems?

“…Third, among such young children refusals, drop-outs, and exclusions for motion-flawed data were not uncommon, potentially biasing results, although validity is suggested by certain strong consistencies ( e.g., before risky behaviors all (of many) significant activation:externalizing associations were negative). And again, the similar neural dysfunction of these children and troubled adolescents (Alegria et al, 2016; Raschle et al, 2015; Rogers and De Brito, 2016), although unfortunate, is reassuring.…”

“…Second, our discussion compares children reported here and adolescents reported elsewhere (Alegria et al, 2016; Raschle et al, 2015; Rogers and De Brito, 2016). Such cross-sectional comparisons should inform, but cannot replace, future longitudinal studies.…”

“…Also, Raschle et al (2015) reported two meta-analyses of studies examining adolescents with serious aggressive behavior. First, in volumetric studies aggression-associated deficiencies in gray-matter volume overlapped almost perfectly with regions in our Table 2.…”

What can be learned from white matter alterations in antisocial girls.

“…In line with individual reports, meta-analyses have summarized that brain regions commonly affected in conduct disorder are part of specific neural networks, specifically the emotion processing and regulation network (see figure 1) 18,19 . Brain areas within those networks are functionally and structurally interconnected with one another by anatomical white matter tracts consisting of abundant thin myelinated axons.…”

Neurobiological underpinnings of cyberbullying: A pilot functional magnetic resonance imaging study

“…From a structural perspective, a study of 9-to 18-year-old males and females found that callous-unemotional traits are related to variations in brain structure (i.e., gray matter volume of the bilateral anterior insular cortices), but only in males (Raschle et al, 2018). Other research suggests that aggressive behavior might originate from an impairment of both recognition of stimuli that depict emotional valence and cognitive control of emotional behavior (Sterzer, Stadler, Krebs, Kleinschmidt, & Poustka, 2005), and that adolescents with aggressive behavior may also have significant differences in emotion processing and regulation networks (including orbitofrontal, dorsomedial prefrontal, and limbic cortex) (Raschle, Menks, Fehlbaum, Tshomba, & Stadler, 2015).…”