Streptococcus suis serotype 2 strains can cause severe infections in both swine and humans. The capsular polysaccharide (CPS) of S. suis defines various serotypes based on its composition and structure. Though serotype switching from serotype 2 has been suggested to occur between S. suis strains, its impact on pathogenicity and virulence remains unknown. Herein, we experimentally generated S. suis serotype-switched mutants from a serotype 2 strain (SS2) that express the serotype 3, 4, 7, 8, 9, or 14 CPS (SS2to3, SS2to4, SS2to7, SS2to8, SS2to9, and SS2to14, respectively). The effects of serotype switching were then investigated with regards to classical properties conferred by presence of the serotype 2 CPS, including adhesion to/invasion of porcine tracheal epithelial cells, resistance to phagocytosis by murine macrophages, killing by murine and porcine whole blood, and dendritic cell-derived pro-inflammatory mediator production. Results demonstrated that these properties on host cell interactions were differentially modulated depending on the switched serotypes. Using a mouse model of systemic infection, SS2to8 was demonstrated to be hyper-virulent, with animals rapidly succumbing to septic shock, whereas SS2to3 and SS2to4 were less virulent than SS2 because of a reduced systemic inflammatory host response. By contrast, switching to serotype 7, 9, or 14 CPSs had little to no effect. Finally, development of clinical signs in a porcine model of infection was only observed following infection with SS2, SS2to7, and SS2to8. Taken together, these findings suggest that serotype switching can differentially modulate S. suis host cell interactions and virulence depending on the CPS type expressed.