Student feedback experiences in a cross-border medical education curriculum

Abstract

ObjectivesTo determine non-Western situated health professional student experiences and preferences for feedback in workplace-based settings. MethodsWe conducted five focus groups with 27 students of Arab-origin enrolled in a Canadian-accredited cross-border pharmacy program in Qatar. Transcripts of recorded discussions were analyzed using the framework method. Hofstede’s and Hall’s cultural dimension models were employed to understand described feedback encounters and behaviours. ResultsWe identified three themes associated with cultural influences on student feedback experiences, namely: 1) collectivism; 2) power distance; and 3) context. Trainees described clinical supervisors who inadequately recognized individual performance, rejected critique, and insufficiently documented feedback onto the written in-training evaluation report. Conversely, students expected specific and timely feedback, invited criticism for learning, and desired clear written commentary. ConclusionsFeedback behaviours of clinical supervisors, but not those of trainees, were consistent with local cultural norms as described by Hofstede and Hall. Instead, feedback expectations of pharmacy students in Qatar largely echo those of other trainees enrolled in professional curricula situated outside the Middle East. Principles for optimal feedback in clinical training largely arise from Western perspectives but are not necessarily universal. Our work demonstrates that practices, in part, may be subject to local socio-cultural influences. This is of particular importance in the experiential training component of cross-border medical education programs adopted by overseas institutions. Our findings also further add to the growing body of literature reporting suboptimal feedback in workplace-based learning, reinforcing the need to cultivate more student-centered practices in health professional training globally.

Exploring Feedback Mechanics during Experiential Learning in Pharmacy Education: A Scoping Review

“…After removing duplicates (n = 521), titles and abstracts of 822 articles were screened, resulting in 27 full-text articles being retrieved and reviewed for eligibility against inclusion and exclusion criteria. This yielded 13 articles [ 16 , 17 , 18 , 19 , 20 , 21 , 22 , 23 , 24 , 25 , 26 , 27 , 28 ] that were subsequently included in this review.…”

Enhancing clinical skills in pediatric trainees: a comparative study of ChatGPT-assisted and traditional teaching methods

“…ChatGPT’s proficiency in tailoring educational content to individual performance metrics propels a more incisive and efficacious learning journey. Furthermore, the on-site, real-time feedback from evaluators is likely instrumental in consolidating clinical skillsets, echoing findings on the potency of immediate feedback in clinical education [ 15 , 16 ].…”

Culture and understanding the role of feedback for health professions students: realist synthesis protocol

“…Furthermore, feedback value is influenced by the credibility of the feedback source. [8][9][10] As it is essential to close the feedback loop, we can think of feedback as sense-making in the context of information provided from many sources to improve work and learning. 11 The importance of relationships and trust between the supervisor and trainee, especially when the feedback relates to assessment, has been emphasised.…”