Study of the relationship between dimensional performance and manufacturing cost in fused deposition modeling

Abstract

Purpose Quantifying and controlling the quality characteristics of parts produced by additive manufacturing (AM) processes has attracted significant interest in the research community. However, to increase the sustainability of AM processes, such quality characteristics need to be assessed together with life cycle performance of AM processes such as energy and material consumption and manufacturing cost. Although a few studies have been performed for several quality characteristics, i.e. surface roughness and tensile strength, the relationship between dimensional performance and manufacturing cost is still not well known for AM processes. Design/methodology/approach In this paper, a comprehensive study of the dimensional performance and manufacturing cost of fused deposition modeling AM process is performed. Design of experiment technique is used, and the correlation of different cost components and the dimensional accuracy of parts are statistically studied. Findings The optimum process parameters for simultaneously optimizing the dimensional performance and manufacturing cost are identified. The analysis shows that as opposed to traditional manufacturing processes, obtaining a better dimensional performance is not necessarily associated with higher cost in the AM processes. Originality/value Almost no study and analysis for the combined dimensional performance and manufacturing cost has been performed for AM processes in the literature. It is known that within the context of traditional manufacturing processes, a natural trade-off governs the pursuit of higher dimensional performance and the manufacturing cost. However, as the AM process has a different nature compared with traditional manufacturing processes, the relationship between manufacturing cost and dimensional performance of parts has to be studied. Understanding this relationship will also help to establish a cost-optimal and sustainable tolerance allocation strategy in assemblies with AM components.

Fused deposition modelling: a review

“…Mahmood et al (2018) showed that the number of shells remained the utmost influential factor. Haghighi and Li (2018) observed that building orientation in the Z-direction was found to be significant because it reduces fill density, cost and dimensional variation.…”

“…At X-axis at 0° part, orientation parts have a medium cost requirement. Haghighi and Li (2018) performed a comprehensive analysis of manufacturing cost (includes material cost, energy cost and operational cost). According to results, orientation in Z-direction is preferred over the XY plane.…”

Modeling, analysis, and optimization of dimensional accuracy of FDM-fabricated parts using definitive screening design and deep learning feedforward artificial neural network

“…FEA results confirmed that the dimensional accuracy was highly affected by the height of the parts, and that shrinkage was significant at the outer frame of the built parts. Haghighi and Li [17] investigated the relationship between the dimensional accuracy and processing cost of FDM-fabricated parts. The optimum setting of FDM fabrication parameters for simultaneously improving the dimensional accuracy and processing cost were determined using the desirability function.…”

Experimental study on tensile strength of copper microparticles filled polymer composites printed by fused deposition modelling process

“…Moreover, this method is fast and cost-effective compared to other manufacturing methods. In this regard, it has revolutionized the production of mechanical parts (Vyavahare et al, 2020;McCaw and Cuan-Urquizo, 2020;Haghighi and Li, 2018;Paul et al, 2018).…”